I think the issue is the perception of an 'ideal' or 'perfect' suit is very subjective and different for everyone. This is made even more complex by tailors having different strengths.
When we talk about quality tailoring, we mean:
- Quality fit ( This is a given as we are tailoring and not buying RTW clothes. The reason to tailor is because we want a great fit)
- Quality construction
- Quality fabrics
- Quality aesthetics ( e.g pick stitching and Milanese buttonhole that doesn't add much functionality)
- Quality price and therefore value
Price has a direct relationship with quality of construction, fabrics and aesthetics. Different people have different needs and different budgets. A banker may well afford a full canvassed suit for the added durability as the suit is worn daily/often. However, someone who wears a suit to attend 1-2 wedding dinners a year may not require a full canvassed suit.
And precisely because people have different needs and budgets, there are also different tailors with different price points to cater to them, e.g Bespoke, MTM or the neighbourhood tailor or alteration shop like Seah Im tailor. They have their own clientele and survive enough to create their own value to their customers. Their customers in turn have their own opinions/preference on what "works for them" and express them here.
Ultimately, you are the one tailoring and if you are happy with your tailoring experience, who can tell you otherwise? This forum is on "where to tailor clothes" , the title is broad enough to encompass different types of tailoring customers, not just the customers with bespoke tailoring budgets. While many forumers can post their opinions, ultimately, it is yourself to do your own due diligence and make your own judgement because only yourself know what you need or want best and your financial situation.
Have fun tailoring!