Working Shoe for Young Exec - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
When I think about welting / construction choices, and sole choices.... I think about a few things and what my priorities are.
1) Water permeability of the sole.
2) "Strength" of construction / welting process. And it's inherent water resistance.
3) Is there an aesthetic concern?

Now, how are some of the ways one might get their feet wet?
1) Through direct seepage from the outsole, up through the filler, then through the insole, and to your feet.
2) Through the weakest link in the shoe, where the uppers and the outsole meet. This is where welting and construction come into play.
3) Directly through soaking of the uppers.

Now, it is time to discuss:
1) Outsole material:
Rubber will be impermeable to water. Rubber is also immune to mould growth (bigger factor for me). This is probably the best material for our monsoon season. Many options here... Rubber topy, Tomir sole, Dainite (single / double), Victory, Commando. Apart from the first 2, sole profiles get progressively bulkier, but also more capable of taking a beating. Single dainite is fairly sleek IMO, with a side profile hardly discernible from single leather soles. It is also fairly flexible and comfortable to walk in.
Double leather soles while maybe offering more buffer (before being soaked through) in wet weather, is just as permeable to water as single leather soles, and just as vulnerable to mould growth if stored in humid conditions after a soaking. It is also a little stiffer to walk in.

2) Strength of construction / welting:
When you analyse each component of the welting process, you'll actually realise that almost EVERYTHING is permeable to water, EXCEPT the waxed linen thread for inseaming / outsole stitching (for a handwelted shoe). Blake stitched would be most vulnerable, then GYW, then Blake Rapid, then handwelt, then Norwegian, in that order.
Storm welting is just a modified GYW method where there is an additional raised "vertical" rib on the welt, that goes up the edges of the uppers closest to the welt. Nothing fancy. And probably just some additional "protection", probably not a lot, and also a good deal chunkier. Also machine made. I wouldn't exactly say this is more water resistant than a properly done handwelted shoe.

Norwegian is the most water resistant of all. The main difference is that the uppers are turned outwards instead of inwards, with stitching between:
- the uppers and insole
- the outward turned uppers and a midsole
- the midsole and the outsole
Only can be done by hand.

Of significant mention, there's an even tougher construction method (veldtschoen) where there is a welt in addition to a midsole.
 
Last edited:

darthsid11111

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2015
Messages
6,393
Reaction score
60
When I think about welting / construction choices, and sole choices.... I think about a few things and what my priorities are.
1) Water permeability of the sole.
2) "Strength" of construction / welting process. And it's inherent water resistance.
3) Is there an aesthetic concern?

Now, how are some of the ways one might get their feet wet?
1) Through direct seepage from the outsole, up through the filler, then through the insole, and to your feet.
2) Through the weakest link in the shoe, where the uppers and the outsole meet. This is where welting and construction come into play.
3) Directly through soaking of the uppers.

Now, it is time to discuss:
1) Outsole material:
Rubber will be impermeable to water. Rubber is also immune to mould growth (bigger factor for me). This is probably the best material for our monsoon season. Many options here... Rubber topy, Tomir sole, Dainite (single / double), Victory, Commando. Apart from the first 2, sole profiles get progressively bulkier, but also more capable of taking a beating. Single dainite is fairly sleek IMO, with a side profile hardly discernible from single leather soles. It is also fairly flexible and comfortable to walk in.
Double leather soles while maybe offering more buffer (before being soaked through) in wet weather, is just as permeable to water as single leather soles, and just as vulnerable to mould growth if stored in humid conditions after a soaking. It is also a little stiffer to walk in.

2) Strength of construction / welting:
When you analyse each component of the welting process, you'll actually realise that almost EVERYTHING is permeable to water, EXCEPT the waxed linen thread for inseaming / outsole stitching (for a handwelted shoe). Blake stitched would be most vulnerable, then GYW, then Blake Rapid, then handwelt, then Norwegian, in that order.
Storm welting is just a modified GYW method where there is an additional raised "vertical" rib on the welt, that goes up the edges of the uppers closest to the welt. Nothing fancy. And probably just some additional "protection", probably not a lot, and also a good deal chunkier. Also machine made. I wouldn't exactly say this is more water resistant than a properly done handwelted shoe.

Norwegian is the most water resistant of all. The main difference is that the uppers are turned outwards instead of inwards, with stitching between:
- the uppers and insole
- the outward turned uppers and a midsole
- the midsole and the outsole
Only can be done by hand.

Of significant mention, there's an even tougher construction method (veldtschoen) where there is a welt in addition to a midsole.
Thanks for this!

It is extremely informative, above and beyond what I had expected as when I first posted my question.

Sent from LGE LG-H815 using GAGT
 
Last edited:

walk_the_talk

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 13, 2016
Messages
20
Reaction score
0
Here is my $20 method


Bo bian cuz my walk style always destroy the toe first

Where did u get this done bro? DIY or cobbler? Have been looking for an option like this but the last time I enquired, K&K does not do this - and I do not know why.

Just like you, my gait causes the toe part to wear out much faster than other parts of the sole. While there is always an option to slap on a full vibram, I prefer the "raw" feel of the leather sole and personally prefer to just have vibram installed at the tip of the soles. Especially since we do not have access to reasonably priced flushed metal toe tap installations
 

supernova

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2008
Messages
1,067
Reaction score
0
Why would you want to install a metal toe-tap? I find them a little noisy. Other than it being aesthetically pleasing. I think rubber toe-taps, or simply slapping on a vibram rubber half soles work well too.


Haven't quite considered rubber toe taps. Probably going that route after seeing examples from i_got_a_question_to_ask. Not too keen on full topy or vibram. Reason for toe cap is because I wear out the toes faster. My closed channel GYW is starting to become open channel...
 

supernova

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2008
Messages
1,067
Reaction score
0
When I think about welting / construction choices, and sole choices.... I think about a few things and what my priorities are.
1) Water permeability of the sole.
2) "Strength" of construction / welting process. And it's inherent water resistance.
3) Is there an aesthetic concern?

Now, how are some of the ways one might get their feet wet?
1) Through direct seepage from the outsole, up through the filler, then through the insole, and to your feet.
2) Through the weakest link in the shoe, where the uppers and the outsole meet. This is where welting and construction come into play.
3) Directly through soaking of the uppers.

Now, it is time to discuss:
1) Outsole material:
Rubber will be impermeable to water. Rubber is also immune to mould growth (bigger factor for me). This is probably the best material for our monsoon season. Many options here... Rubber topy, Tomir sole, Dainite (single / double), Victory, Commando. Apart from the first 2, sole profiles get progressively bulkier, but also more capable of taking a beating. Single dainite is fairly sleek IMO, with a side profile hardly discernible from single leather soles. It is also fairly flexible and comfortable to walk in.
Double leather soles while maybe offering more buffer (before being soaked through) in wet weather, is just as permeable to water as single leather soles, and just as vulnerable to mould growth if stored in humid conditions after a soaking. It is also a little stiffer to walk in.

2) Strength of construction / welting:
When you analyse each component of the welting process, you'll actually realise that almost EVERYTHING is permeable to water, EXCEPT the waxed linen thread for inseaming / outsole stitching (for a handwelted shoe). Blake stitched would be most vulnerable, then GYW, then Blake Rapid, then handwelt, then Norwegian, in that order.
Storm welting is just a modified GYW method where there is an additional raised "vertical" rib on the welt, that goes up the edges of the uppers closest to the welt. Nothing fancy. And probably just some additional "protection", probably not a lot, and also a good deal chunkier. Also machine made. I wouldn't exactly say this is more water resistant than a properly done handwelted shoe.

Norwegian is the most water resistant of all. The main difference is that the uppers are turned outwards instead of inwards, with stitching between:
- the uppers and insole
- the outward turned uppers and a midsole
- the midsole and the outsole
Only can be done by hand.

Of significant mention, there's an even tougher construction method (veldtschoen) where there is a welt in addition to a midsole.

Thanks for sharing. This is very informative. How about uppers? Are suede more waterproof?

I tend to favour dainite soles for the lower end GYW shoes with open channel :) just got a pair of Carlos santos suede chukka with dainite sole. Works well in the rain. Sole is super hard though... And chukka causes blisters at a different place than other shoes....
 

All in a Day

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 3, 2014
Messages
14,850
Reaction score
1,560
just bought a pair of Loake Hyde from robinson's shoes . any reviews?

Strange that u're asking for review AFTER buying the shoes. The review should be from u rather? Lol

Anyway i think they should meet expectations of the 1880 standard and capital last is a fairly safe fit unless one has narrow feet.
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
Thanks for sharing. This is very informative. How about uppers? Are suede more waterproof?

I tend to favour dainite soles for the lower end GYW shoes with open channel :) just got a pair of Carlos santos suede chukka with dainite sole. Works well in the rain. Sole is super hard though... And chukka causes blisters at a different place than other shoes....

One must consider the nature of leather, and what it goes through during the tanning process, to answer this question better.
Starting with the hide.
Hide is essentially the skin of an animal.
In a living animal, skin is (largely) waterproof because the epidermis is keratinised. The keratin layer is impervious to water. Natural oils and fat in skin / subdermal fat also aids in repelling water.
When the animal is killed and the hide harvested, it must quickly undergo a process to both preserve it and make it ready and suitable for shoe making. This is the principle of tanning.
During the tanning process, a lot of these natural oils are removed (to prevent degradation). This results in some loss of suppleness and water resistance.
Chromium molecules binding to the collagen helices do aid somewhat in returning water resistance properties back to the leather.
Tanners and leather makers will "add back" some of the oils nearer the end of the tanning process. For example, hot stuffing oils may be performed to produce an oily, fairly water resistant leather like chromexcel and other pullup leathers.
The finishing process (apart from dyes and colors) may involve a topcoat which then confers additional water resistant properties to the hide.
Suede, by and large is not a "complete' hide, but rather a split. Meaning the prime part of the hide (the one with the grain surface) has been split away. And then the remaining is buffed / sanded to raise a nap, and used as suede. This means the leather is thinner, and it also lacks a grain surface. True suede is actually "reverse calf", where there is still a grain surface, but the leather is used flesh side out. In other words, the splits that we are all used to, is both thinner, and also not "finished" like how most other full grain calf leather is. It is thus less "water resistant". That's why people use nano protector on it.
 
Last edited:

JoePilot

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2011
Messages
10,132
Reaction score
239
I like suede cos creases don't show up, and properly treated ( nano protector, saphir invulner spray) suede can shed off water like rain drops off a lotus leaf. Very cool.
 

i_got_a_question_to_ask

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2007
Messages
7,216
Reaction score
2,224
Many cobbler can do it. About $20.

Buah away the oroginal leather to make flushed rubber toes. Nail down or not is optional. Describe explicitly to your cobbler what you want. Or show them my picture la.
 

likehotbutter

Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2010
Messages
5,797
Reaction score
816
Another thing about suede

The flesh side out variant (roughout) is more sturdy than the buffed/split variant.

WWII marine boots you see throughout the Pacific Campaign were made of roughout, which was cheaper as you didnt need to line them.

Aesthetic wise however, the nap is shaggier then the buffed/spilt variety, which may not be so ideal for fine shoes
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
Another thing about suede

The flesh side out variant (roughout) is more sturdy than the buffed/split variant.

WWII marine boots you see throughout the Pacific Campaign were made of roughout, which was cheaper as you didnt need to line them.

Aesthetic wise however, the nap is shaggier then the buffed/spilt variety, which may not be so ideal for fine shoes

Not necessarily so.
Most if not all the best bespoke makers use reverse calf for their suede shoes, it's only right.
The nap can be incredibly fine.
Take a look at some of the Jap bespoke guys' suede stuff. Beyond comparison.
 

likehotbutter

Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2010
Messages
5,797
Reaction score
816
Not necessarily so.
Most if not all the best bespoke makers use reverse calf for their suede shoes, it's only right.
The nap can be incredibly fine.
Take a look at some of the Jap bespoke guys' suede stuff. Beyond comparison.

I meant for roughout in its unadulterated form with the fleshside left as it is, which is inherently shaggy

If a fleshside suede is to present an even soft nap, then that means buffing past the flesh layer to the corium strata would be required

On the basis of this directional presentation of fibres, I amongst others (like dwf lol) feel that this is inferior compared to the version been buffed down from the grain side instead (aka nubuck)

But then again only general assumptions can be made as other stuff like hide quality and tannage will play an equally big role as well.
 

patryn33

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Apr 10, 2006
Messages
23,202
Reaction score
80
Not necessarily so.
Most if not all the best bespoke makers use reverse calf for their suede shoes, it's only right.
The nap can be incredibly fine.
Take a look at some of the Jap bespoke guys' suede stuff. Beyond comparison.

Those jap process their leather before making shoes?
Or their source provide them with good stuff, at jap bespoke price only jap offer such quality? Vass and the likes cannot match?

When u say fine it's not snuffed as stated below?
http://www.rancourtandcompany.com/leathers
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
I meant for roughout in its unadulterated form with the fleshside left as it is, which is inherently shaggy

If a fleshside suede is to present an even soft nap, then that means buffing past the flesh layer to the corium strata would be required

On the basis of this directional presentation of fibres, I amongst others (like dwf lol) feel that this is inferior compared to the version been buffed down from the grain side instead (aka nubuck)

But then again only general assumptions can be made as other stuff like hide quality and tannage will play an equally big role as well.

Well, the original discussion was between a split suede and reverse calf.
So your earlier post seemed to imply that splits would be more suitable for fine work as compared to reverse calf, which simply isn't correct. Splits will always be inferior to reverse calf. And plenty of reverse calf is used for fine work.
That being said, nubuck and reverse calf are both preferable to split suedes.
Nubuck is particularly preferable, I find, when you want to preserve the look a unique grain surface / pattern, yet want the texture of suede.
 

thundermarch

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2013
Messages
1,082
Reaction score
0
Those jap process their leather before making shoes?
Or their source provide them with good stuff, at jap bespoke price only jap offer such quality? Vass and the likes cannot match?

When u say fine it's not snuffed as stated below?
http://www.rancourtandcompany.com/leathers

Well, when you say finish... some Japanese makers do go through some form of a patination process mainly to alter the surface appearance of the leather, the color , etc.
It's a strictly cosmetic process.
Yohei, for one, does this quite a bit, when asked to.
A lot of them also use the leather as it is, preferring to let the leather speak for itself.
After speaking to a number of these makers, I know for a fact they take pride in sourcing for good leather to begin with.
You can't buy crap leather and end up with good shoes.
I find Japanese work fairly stellar. It's not cheap by any standards, but very very reasonable when compared to English and French bespoke makers.
Light years ahead of what Vass can offer. It's not even remotely close.
That being said, I think that for what the Austro-Hungarian makers charge, they too, offer pretty good value. Especially Maftei.
 
Last edited:

likehotbutter

Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2010
Messages
5,797
Reaction score
816
Well, the original discussion was between a split suede and reverse calf.
So your earlier post seemed to imply that splits would be more suitable for fine work as compared to reverse calf, which simply isn't correct.

Indeed!

Looking back, should have made a clearer distinction between buffed and split suede instead of lumping them together lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top