9K for NSmen doing NS.

alfy

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2000
Messages
1,546
Reaction score
1
Singaporeans being jealous of FTs should take a good look at themselves first.
Have you never have the thought of migrating to a 'better' country yourself?
Don't forget that you'll be a FT yourself in the other country.

BTW,
don't flame me...I'm 100% Singaporean.
 

sunzoner

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2002
Messages
14,864
Reaction score
343
Singaporeans being jealous of FTs should take a good look at themselves first.
Have you never have the thought of migrating to a 'better' country yourself?
Don't forget that you'll be a FT yourself in the other country.

BTW,
don't flame me...I'm 100% Singaporean.

Good tactics. when cannot win, ask your opponents to go away... In this case, ask those who are unhappy to leave...
 

ScootS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
732
Reaction score
0
Singaporeans being jealous of FTs should take a good look at themselves first.
Have you never have the thought of migrating to a 'better' country yourself?
Don't forget that you'll be a FT yourself in the other country.

BTW,
don't flame me...I'm 100% Singaporean.

To correct you:
I am not jealous of FTs.
I am upset with my own government's policies which favours FTs in their quest to increase GDP. A growth which has NOT filtered down and translate to citizens being better off. On the contrary, most citizens feel that they are worse off
 
Last edited:

zoossh

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2000
Messages
86,731
Reaction score
19,251
Caroline-Migros-p1000507.jpg


swiss ns men allow to do this
our ns men after range even 1 bullet got to kena few times declaration.

slovakia just got a rifle massacre. gunner suicide thereafter. motive uncertain.

most ppl do not agree with what's going on in the army, some out of concern, some out of personal grievances. but i dun think going the other extreme is good either.
 

zoossh

Greater Supremacy Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2000
Messages
86,731
Reaction score
19,251
Singaporeans being jealous of FTs should take a good look at themselves first.
Have you never have the thought of migrating to a 'better' country yourself?
Don't forget that you'll be a FT yourself in the other country.

BTW,
don't flame me...I'm 100% Singaporean.

i dun think "jealous" is an appropriate term for the past 10-20 years. the foreign workforce is no longer all only a tiny group of elite high-flyers, perhaps it is 30 years ago, where envy and jealousy may be a case.

on the other hand, well behaved migrants who make the best of what they can get is not wrong.

my stand is
1. keep foreign demographics, including naturalised citizens, below 10%.
2. regulated immigration, for expertise required but not available in sg, e.g. physiotherapists.
3. maintain privileges of local borns of local parentage.
4. well-distributed wealth should precede overall income of a state.
 
Last edited:

Ferrari^^

Banned
Joined
Mar 2, 2008
Messages
2,558
Reaction score
0
based on the link, seems like:

1. those who ORDed before 29 Aug 2010 will get nothing. Therefore will get less than the $9000 promised by PM.
2. those who completes their midpoint of ORNC (aka reservist training) before the announce will get $3000 only.
3. Those who completes their cycle get nothing at all.

Hows that for recognition?

come on the ppl in mycarforum are ok with taking it and i believe they are of a better financial standing....i cannot believe what the ppl here are saying...i am not defending the government in anyway.....but its is impossible to be equal for everyone....even my time as an nsf was reduced by 2 months only...and you guys are talking as though u dun need the 9k....anyway what gives? :s13:
 

Ferrari^^

Banned
Joined
Mar 2, 2008
Messages
2,558
Reaction score
0
To correct you:
I am not jealous of FTs.
I am upset with my own government's policies which favours FTs in their quest to increase GDP. A growth which has NOT filtered down and translate to citizens being better off. On the contrary, most citizens feel that they are worse off

so what are u gonna do? take an m-16 rifle and shoot them? divide singapore? one is called east singapore and the other west singapore?

one for area for true singaporeans, another for PRs` or immigrants?

you cant change things man....its either you look at it positively, prove your ability and do the best you can to compete with PRs foreign workers immigrants and outshine them, or jus be negative and keep complaining and cry in bed....so its up to the individual....

anyway to add on being in the military has taught me alot of things, its either u make the best of the situation or die trying.... :s13: and to add on there is only one route in the military anyway, that is to be the best

and i quite like IPPT anyway keeps mi fit...and it is good to run sometimes....and of course getting the monetary award

actually i should not comment too much on this topic....the smarter ones will just keep quiet
 

clocksprings

Supremacy Member
Joined
May 19, 2008
Messages
9,732
Reaction score
13
come on the ppl in mycarforum are ok with taking it and i believe they are of a better financial standing....i cannot believe what the ppl here are saying...i am not defending the government in anyway.....but its is impossible to be equal for everyone....even my time as an nsf was reduced by 2 months only...and you guys are talking as though u dun need the 9k....anyway what gives? :s13:

It's like someone gives you 100 bucks, but spits on it and makes you crawl under his legs before you can get it, and even then the money is in the form of a check which you cannot cash anytime you want :s8:
 

ScootS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2003
Messages
732
Reaction score
0
so what are u gonna do? take an m-16 rifle and shoot them? divide singapore? one is called east singapore and the other west singapore?

one for area for true singaporeans, another for PRs` or immigrants?

you cant change things man....its either you look at it positively, prove your ability and do the best you can to compete with PRs foreign workers immigrants and outshine them, or jus be negative and keep complaining and cry in bed....so its up to the individual....

anyway to add on being in the military has taught me alot of things, its either u make the best of the situation or die trying.... :s13: and to add on there is only one route in the military anyway, that is to be the best

and i quite like IPPT anyway keeps mi fit...and it is good to run sometimes....and of course getting the monetary award

actually i should not comment too much on this topic....the smarter ones will just keep quiet

I do not agree with either of your proposals as they are both defeatists attitude.

Defeatist in that you accept that it's right to erode any citizens standing in his country by accepting that the government doesn't have an obligation to work to improve the citizens in value and well being

Defeatist in that you think that the only form of disagreement equates to despair

And obviously, being in the miliary, you are sheltered from the events that's happening in the real world ... it's very easy advocating for something when it does not affect you. So much for being the 'best'
 

The_Davis

High Honorary Member
Deluxe Member
Joined
Mar 31, 2001
Messages
152,497
Reaction score
15,027
sorry why did people think cancer81 is not singaporean?
 

Visitor

Master Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
4,293
Reaction score
0
let me add abit fuel for the fun, here goes:

Do you know if you take 9k money from "some group" for a NS "grad".
you take 9k for this year,
you take 9k for next year
you take 9k for next next year.
you take again 9k for next next next year.
and so on and so forth.

If you are today to get 9k and in a year after you "grad" and start paying tax payer money, you start to cough out that bit for as long as NS boys are "graduating"

Now, do you want that "some group" to be a PRs and foreigners paying or you want that "some group" to be a local born.

Consider that the KPI for local born is already so high, dont you think it is time to increase the KPI for our PRs and Foreigners. and see if they would give it or fuc*k it...
:s13:

How you know how much it is paying out. well take your IC and look at the number and the date you are born, ratio to 12, you will have the rough guide on the number of babys born and divide by 2.
for the sake of simplicity.
$9k * no of boys
 
Last edited:

sunzoner

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2002
Messages
14,864
Reaction score
343
sorry why did people think cancer81 is not singaporean?

iirc, cancer81 had said that he is not born a singaporean, thus leading me to think he is in fact either a PR or naturalised Singaporean.

I also tot he mention that he did not serve NS. Thus when he say he did, I asked if he is indeed a male. This lead to questions on his gender. The part about him not being a singaporean did not surface...
 

sunzoner

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2002
Messages
14,864
Reaction score
343
come on the ppl in mycarforum are ok with taking it and i believe they are of a better financial standing....i cannot believe what the ppl here are saying...i am not defending the government in anyway.....but its is impossible to be equal for everyone....even my time as an nsf was reduced by 2 months only...and you guys are talking as though u dun need the 9k....anyway what gives? :s13:

Please note PM's speech quoted below.

He said:
This will be a significant token to appreciate the contributions of citizens who have served NS

Note the bold and underlined. It is in past tense. Meaning, those who used to serve NS. Thus means everyone who had served NS. These people may still be serving their ICTs (commonly called reservist or ORNS) or maybe not.

The policy detail announcement following his speech seems to be not in line with what the PM announced. As a citizen of a democratic country, we should not talk about it when policy details seems to contradict the announcement of the people-elected Prime Minister?


National Day Rally Speech (English) by Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong on 29 August 2010, at 8.00pm at University Cultural Centre, National University of Singapore

http://www.pmo.gov.sg/News/Speeches...+PM+Lee+at+University+Cultural+Centre+NUS.htm

40. Third, tied up with loyalty and commitment is NS

a. A heavy demand on citizens

i. Two years full-time

ii. Then more years as ORNS, while trying to build a career and raise a family

b. Unfortunately not practical to make foreign workers and adult immigrants do NS

i. But their children will serve

ii. Many PRs and first generation citizens have done NS

iii. Still, sense that citizens are carrying a heavy burden

41. Hence we do all we can to recognise the contributions and sacrifices of our NSmen

a. SAFRA clubhouses, allowances, tax reliefs, top-ups etc.

b. New initiative – the National Service Recognition Award (NSRA)

i. Help with the cost of their subsequent education

ii. Also to buy a house

42. NSRA will be a meaningful sum

a. In total $9,000

b. Commanders will receive more

c. In tranches, paid at major milestones of an NSman’s service

d. Into his PSEA and CPF accounts

e. For citizens only

f. PRs who have done NS will receive the NSRA when they take up citizenship

43. This will be a significant token to appreciate the contributions of citizens who have served NS
 

sunzoner

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2002
Messages
14,864
Reaction score
343
How about we pay the state $9000 and no need to serve NS and reservist training?:s12:

The payment should be broken down into 3 portions with payment milestones tied to the supposed serving of the NS and reservist training.
 

Fatfool

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Messages
32,307
Reaction score
107
based on the link, seems like:

1. those who ORDed before 29 Aug 2010 will get nothing. Therefore will get less than the $9000 promised by PM.
2. those who completes their midpoint of ORNC (aka reservist training) before the announce will get $3000 only.
3. Those who completes their cycle get nothing at all.

Hows that for recognition?

Wah! SO SINCERE SIA!!! :s31:

Discounting the fact that the amount is in CPF aka virtual/neopets money, and even the full '$9000' and career advancement. let's see.

Let's take a Diploma Holder as the average and $2000 as a monthly salary. (ignore much higher salaries from working after a degree/masters/Phd and lower ones)
Let's take a NSF with an average salary of $500.

2000*24 = 48000
500*24 = 12000

so, 48000 - 12000 - 9000 = 27000

Might I remind readers that working for 2 years for real will net you 27000 more in real liquid cash :s8:
 
Last edited:

snipes14

Supremacy Member
Joined
Mar 13, 2001
Messages
6,127
Reaction score
0
slovakia just got a rifle massacre. gunner suicide thereafter. motive uncertain.

most ppl do not agree with what's going on in the army, some out of concern, some out of personal grievances. but i dun think going the other extreme is good either.

Guns don't kill people, people kill people. For your information people are perfectly capable of killing without guns. For example, the rampages in Akiharaba in Japan. Plow into pedestrians with your car, get out, start slashing people with knife.

Anyway WTF is this ****? Just because I ORD before the magical date of 29th August 2010 I won't get the first $3000? Is my 2 years of service somehow more worthless than some bloke who ORD on the magical date of 29th August 2010?

I'm not angry for myself though. I'm sad for the people who ORD on 28th August 2010. :D
 
Last edited:

Ferrari^^

Banned
Joined
Mar 2, 2008
Messages
2,558
Reaction score
0
Wah! SO SINCERE SIA!!! :s31:

Discounting the fact that the amount is in CPF aka virtual/neopets money, and even the full '$9000' and career advancement. let's see.

Let's take a Diploma Holder as the average and $2000 as a monthly salary. (ignore much higher salaries from working after a degree/masters/Phd and lower ones)
Let's take a NSF with an average salary of $500.

2000*24 = 48000
500*24 = 12000

so, 48000 - 12000 - 9000 = 27000

Might I remind readers that working for 2 years for real will net you 27000 more in real liquid cash :s8:

yes you are correct and it will even be much more for degree and masters holders....not forgetting opportunity cost....

but its is very troublesome there will be alot of implications once you awol and the police will come looking for you....so to avoid all that trouble just clear ippt and attend the ICT
 

Ferrari^^

Banned
Joined
Mar 2, 2008
Messages
2,558
Reaction score
0
I do not agree with either of your proposals as they are both defeatists attitude.

Defeatist in that you accept that it's right to erode any citizens standing in his country by accepting that the government doesn't have an obligation to work to improve the citizens in value and well being

Defeatist in that you think that the only form of disagreement equates to despair

And obviously, being in the miliary, you are sheltered from the events that's happening in the real world ... it's very easy advocating for something when it does not affect you. So much for being the 'best'

lol maybe so....if i am an "achiever" or "winner" ill be working in a first world country right now...then come back buy a lamborghini or ferrari and the most expensive properties in Singapore, all paid for in full....opps...back to reality..and btw im a civillian....
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top