NP was launched on Jan 2021. There were still loads of units available at Treasure at Tampines. Jadescape, Whistler Grand, Park Colonial, Stirling, Daintree, Clavon, Forett, Penrose, Florence, Parc Clematis still had significant balance units then. PR8, ONE, Midtown Modern, Canninghill Piers, Watergardens etc not yet launched. Disagree on nothing much to buy.
Seemed like NSZ changed his opinion after seeing the post launch sales momentum despite price increases
Anyway, I think those critical of NP values walkable to MRT, near Kopitiam/Hawker & within 1km of popular primary school greatly. I.e Attributes which typical HDB upgrader look for. NP doesn’t offer any of that.
We will see the results in 2024 once SSD expires for some buyers

. I do think ‘smart money’ got NP right.