Eight Telecom discussion thread

xiaofan

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
37,316
Reaction score
12,689
IMHO.
Yeah.. Eight ish no good. 🤣

Good or no good all depends on use case and expectations.

I will keep my eight 4G S$8 plan because of the one for one S$88 top-up offer. At the effective price of S$4 per month for 22 months, cannot complaint much. It is good as a backup and also for roaming (free voice roaming, can upgrade to the S$15.28 5G plan for better roaming bundle when needed).

My main line is Singtel SIM Only S$15.28 plan which is pretty good for local usage but not so good for roaming. For example, I need to pay S$18 for China roaming with 6GB data. Voice roaming is super expensive at S$5 per minute.

If without the top-up offer from eight, at S$8 per month then I may cancel it after a while. Then I will just get SIMBA S$12 prepaid plan or Shopee eSIM for occasional roaming needs.
 

xiaofan

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
37,316
Reaction score
12,689
For people using single main line with eight 4G plans (including S$5 Senior plan), you may really moderate your expectations.

Same for CUniq 4G plan, which is also using StarHub 4G network and has the same congestion issue.

Same for SIMBA. In fact I feel eight 4G is slightly better than SIMBA 5G/4G for local usage.

M1 Maxx 5G and CL 5G are better than eight 4G and SIMBA based on my testing. To me they are also better than SingTel hi! 4G plan.

Then SingTel S$15.28 plan is better than Maxx 5G and CL 5G.

Take note I usually do not take MRT during weekdays, only weekends. So my use case is probably simpler. Still I can feel the obvious differences among the above plans I tried.
 

keenklee

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2000
Messages
19,627
Reaction score
6,875
Good or no good all depends on use case and expectations.

I will keep my eight 4G S$8 plan because of the one for one S$88 top-up offer. At the effective price of S$4 per month for 22 months, cannot complaint much. It is good as a backup and also for roaming (free voice roaming, can upgrade to the S$15.28 5G plan for better roaming bundle when needed).

My main line is Singtel SIM Only S$15.28 plan which is pretty good for local usage but not so good for roaming. For example, I need to pay S$18 for China roaming with 6GB data. Voice roaming is super expensive at S$5 per minute.

If without the top-up offer from eight, at S$8 per month then I may cancel it after a while. Then I will just get SIMBA S$12 prepaid plan or Shopee eSIM for occasional roaming needs.
IMHO.
Eh... relax.... u see the previous post. 🤣
 

Honda_typeR

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2014
Messages
786
Reaction score
149
Probably depends on your expectations.

Peak hours North South Line (especially around Orchard MRT station) is probably one of the most difficult places for all the mobile service providers.

Singtel SIM Only 5G+ Enhanced or Priority plans may indeed be much better but they may still got issues.

StarHub's new 5G Unlimited+ and 5G Platinum plans may also be better (need to see some reports here)

M1 Bespoke SIM Only plans may also be better (need to see some reports here).

Reference from SingTel SIM Only plan thread that SingTel 5G+ Enhanced Lite plan at S$19.25 (CIS offer) was much better than VIVIFI 4G (as expected).
I guess you cannot get the best of both worlds.

Previously M1 Cori local was good, I had 2 lines price 16++ and 17++ PM, Data passport was also good but expensive for the convinence.

Then i chanced upon 8, anyway good or bad am stuck for a year due to the 88+88.

I mean peak hours slow is ok, but completely no network damn pissed la. That was also the reason i ug 8 4g to 5g. now 5g also same problem
 

sibeiTrolled

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2012
Messages
2,075
Reaction score
1,672
I guess you cannot get the best of both worlds.

Previously M1 Cori local was good, I had 2 lines price 16++ and 17++ PM, Data passport was also good but expensive for the convinence.

Then i chanced upon 8, anyway good or bad am stuck for a year due to the 88+88.

I mean peak hours slow is ok, but completely no network damn pissed la. That was also the reason i ug 8 4g to 5g. now 5g also same problem
Unfortunately, we must gradually suck thumb and accept detoriating services, locally and or internationally.

If M1 was good one year back, dosen't mean they are still good now. They are also effectively sharing the same infrastructure as Starhub.
You can try getting a new M1 line, so you can keep your existing one, and try if it's acceptable for you. Then once you are done, can just port that M1 line to Singtel and see if the premium MNO experience is worth the cost.

Let's not count the singtel recontract plans (15 SGD+) that some users are on as they tilt the scale towards favouring singtel MNO
 

xiaofan

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
37,316
Reaction score
12,689
Let's not count the singtel recontract plans (15 SGD+) that some users are on as they tilt the scale towards favouring singtel MNO

Just want to point out this plan is pretty easy to get now.

You need to pay one month S$40 SingTel SIM Only Enhanced Core plan. After that you can recontract to the S$15.28 SingTel SIM Only Plan (12 months contract).
 

yusoffb01

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2008
Messages
16,872
Reaction score
1,790
Yeah it was completely non usable during Mrt peak, thus i switch to 5G eight.

But iffy la, 1 week maybe 3 or 4 days work fine, other 3 days not working.

Damn it I reckon their top up 1 for 1 promo got catch one, cause network only half the time workable so they breakeven.
does 5g help during peak
 

Honda_typeR

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2014
Messages
786
Reaction score
149
Unfortunately, we must gradually suck thumb and accept detoriating services, locally and or internationally.

If M1 was good one year back, dosen't mean they are still good now. They are also effectively sharing the same infrastructure as Starhub.
You can try getting a new M1 line, so you can keep your existing one, and try if it's acceptable for you. Then once you are done, can just port that M1 line to Singtel and see if the premium MNO experience is worth the cost.

Let's not count the singtel recontract plans (15 SGD+) that some users are on as they tilt the scale towards favouring singtel MNO
Yeah I agree it might be different now.

Guess have to trial and error till you hit the sweet spot.

I saw the ST MVNO complaning that some got charge hefty or dubious roaming voice calls.
 

cherynsq

Master Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2025
Messages
2,873
Reaction score
1,305
Sorry I might be missing out on something . What exactly is the benefit of cmlink if I’m going china compared to maybe buy a $6 eSIM on shoppee with 10gb ?
 

cloudystar

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
1,204
Reaction score
677
I guess you cannot get the best of both worlds.

Previously M1 Cori local was good, I had 2 lines price 16++ and 17++ PM, Data passport was also good but expensive for the convinence.

Then i chanced upon 8, anyway good or bad am stuck for a year due to the 88+88.

I mean peak hours slow is ok, but completely no network damn pissed la. That was also the reason i ug 8 4g to 5g. now 5g also same problem
Yes, definitely frustrating there's no network while commuting to work. But such is the situation when travelling at peak hours in crowded areas.

My experience is that some days will be better than others. So it's really depends.

But if it really don't work out, you can try getting a secondary line but there's also a good chance that it will be just as shietty.. :cry:
 

yusoffb01

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 17, 2008
Messages
16,872
Reaction score
1,790
I guess you cannot get the best of both worlds.

Previously M1 Cori local was good, I had 2 lines price 16++ and 17++ PM, Data passport was also good but expensive for the convinence.

Then i chanced upon 8, anyway good or bad am stuck for a year due to the 88+88.

I mean peak hours slow is ok, but completely no network damn pissed la. That was also the reason i ug 8 4g to 5g. now 5g also same problem
ah 5g also congested then no point upgrading. tbf i use simba 5g also cannot load during peak train hours
 

Honda_typeR

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2014
Messages
786
Reaction score
149
Yes, definitely frustrating there's no network while commuting to work. But such is the situation when travelling at peak hours in crowded areas.

My experience is that some days will be better than others. So it's really depends.

But if it really don't work out, you can try getting a secondary line but there's also a good chance that it will be just as shietty.. :cry:
Are you on 5G as well?

Yes agree some days peak Mrt 5G works fine. There are still certain areas blindspots but that is normal i guess and no complaints.
 

Honda_typeR

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 16, 2014
Messages
786
Reaction score
149
ah 5g also congested then no point upgrading. tbf i use simba 5g also cannot load during peak train hours
Base on my observation 5G works resonably 3 quarters of the time.

Previously when i was on 4G it works fine as well, but after a few months it was not working 100% of the time. I dont believe in paying for something when you cannot use it at all.

So i bite the bullet and upgrade 5G thou it cost almost double.

I use wifi at home and office. So travelling in mrt is one of the times i use data and i expect it to be working la. So dont mind paying more.

Able to share your recent 4G experience during peak mrt still usable?
 

JAYSCS

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 30, 2021
Messages
1,216
Reaction score
1,007
Yes, definitely frustrating there's no network while commuting to work. But such is the situation when travelling at peak hours in crowded areas.

My experience is that some days will be better than others. So it's really depends.

But if it really don't work out, you can try getting a secondary line but there's also a good chance that it will be just as shietty.. :cry:
Don't insist on always data connection, it is actually not a bad thing, take a break. Do some eBook reading, listening to free mp3 songs instead of paid spotify, watched download video instead of streaming video especially meaningless mindless tiktoking, use cash or physical card for payments. Treat mobile connection as simple communication tool, then one really will not quite bother with congestion, 4G or 5G speed, etc. Most importantly, savings as the cheapest price plan will suffice. One can still use a smartphone heavily without heavy or seamless data requirement. 😀
 

cloudystar

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2010
Messages
1,204
Reaction score
677
Are you on 5G as well?

Yes agree some days peak Mrt 5G works fine. There are still certain areas blindspots but that is normal i guess and no complaints.
Yes, I'm also on eight 5G and also invested in the $88x2

I also have a MyRepublic 5G (which supposedly have priority per their QCI) but there are moments where MyRepublic 5G went airplane mode but the eight 5G is still fighting strong.

So yeah probably don't read or think too much about how which 'priority' network will be better etc.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top