Gan Siow Huang apologises over handshaking incident at Cantonese cultural festival

coldish

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2008
Messages
37,571
Reaction score
7,879
To be honest, I was actually thinking of maids and foreign workers and NSFs when I wrote the post. They are paid lower than most Singaporeans and do proper job and yet many sinkies seem to have something to complain about them also
I hope you are not downplaying this issue due to sinkies' culture of ppl complain against anything anyway.
If that's so I can only say it is 2 different spectrums here. Political and non-political here.

It is a more serious note here because this involves a MOS, a person who is supposed to have uphold morals n values according to the PM.
So if we are going disregard this issue because we should think that because everyone complains about anyone, regardless of salaries, SES etc anyway, we fail as a basic person.
 

Philipkee

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2013
Messages
26,174
Reaction score
15,432
I hope you are not downplaying this issue due to sinkies' culture of ppl complain against anything anyway.
If that's so I can only say it is 2 different spectrums here. Political and non-political here.
I’m not downplaying anything just pointing out we are all similar
It is a more serious note here because this involves a MOS, a person who is supposed to have uphold morals n values according to the PM.
Interesting. There is a saying that politicians are the worst people you can expect to uphold moral values cos they play politics cos they are politicians. I get it. As people in power, they are expected to show some moral values.

unfortunately, reality is that many will fall short, rhetoric notwithstanding
So if we are going disregard this issue because we should think that because everyone complains about anyone, regardless of salaries, SES etc anyway, we fail as a basic person.
No one, at least not me, is saying disregard the issue but I think we need to also examine ourselves to see if our condemnation is actually simply because she is on the other side of the political divide or because we really feel a moral outrage.

For example, when people did not shake GKY hand, did we condemn those people as rude or suddenly they are heroes?

Not saying the minister was right in this case.
 

coldish

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2008
Messages
37,571
Reaction score
7,879
I’m not downplaying anything just pointing out we are all similar

Interesting. There is a saying that politicians are the worst people you can expect to uphold moral values cos they play politics cos they are politicians. I get it. As people in power, they are expected to show some moral values.

unfortunately, reality is that many will fall short, rhetoric notwithstanding

No one, at least not me, is saying disregard the issue but I think we need to also examine ourselves to see if our condemnation is actually simply because she is on the other side of the political divide or because we really feel a moral outrage.

For example, when people did not shake GKY hand, did we condemn those people as rude or suddenly they are heroes?

Not saying the minister was right in this case.
I don't think politicians are the worst people. After all, PAP claimed they have clean wages and apart from their usual stint of arrogance they do have their decorum and etiquette. And these days PAP falling short is not unexpected given their calibre they have brought in.

Could be either or both political divide and moral condemnation. I am sure there are PAP people who feels disgusted over the issue as well just like how oppies would feel the same way when oppie members have fallen short, example; Andre Low.

Now, you pointed out about GKY shaking hands event vs GSH's
It is not a fair comparison.
One is a private event - welcome party to GSH
One is public event - GKY reaching out to residents during GE

I am sure we are wise enough to extract the bad out of this dichotomy.
 

jonesftw

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2010
Messages
60,451
Reaction score
15,881
guy dua kee enuff to be on news?

A cultural group has released footage to clear the air over a handshake incident that led to criticism online of Minister of State for Foreign Affairs and Trade and Industry Gan Siow Huang.

Kwong Wai Siew Peck San Theng said they had invited Ms Gan for a Cantonese cultural festival held at Peck San Theng in Bishan Lane on May 17.

Representatives of the 155-year-old cultural institution, which is managed by 16 Cantonese clan associations, were waiting to greet her when she arrived alone.

The footage shows her alighting from the car, with a mobile phone in her right hand. She then slips the phone into her rear right trousers pocket as representatives of the group approach her.

Among those who extended their hand was Mr Leong Chee Leng.

The 72-year-old is a member of the Kong Chow Wui Koon lion dance troupe, which was scheduled to perform at the Cantonese cultural festival.

Mr Leong Chee Leng can be seen extending his hand to greet her, but Ms Gan is also approached by Mr Edward Leong, the chairman of the cultural festival’s organising committee.

After shaking hands with Mr Edward Leong, Ms Gan takes Mr Leong Chee Leng’s hand, and then proceeds to shake the hands of several others gathered at the carpark.

The footage was shown at a press conference held by the cultural institution on June 13 at Peck San Theng.

Mr Leong Chee Leng, who was at the press conference, said he noticed that Ms Gan was momentarily distracted by her mobile phone and when somebody else approached her, but did eventually shake his hand.

He said in Mandarin: “(Ms Gan) is really very polite. It’s not like what you imagine from the video. Why do netizens want to attack me and the minister?”

Ms Gan had on June 8 apologised after a video, shot by somebody in the lion dance troupe, made the rounds on social media.

Ms Gan, who is the MP for Marymount SMC, told The Straits Times that it was her first visit to Peck San Theng, and she was overwhelmed by the group that went to greet her.

“When I got out of the car, I was trying to identify the host of Peck San Theng and shake hands with the host first,” she said.

“I was also a little overwhelmed by the big group that received me when I got out of my car. I sincerely apologise to the man in the red shirt for the delay in shaking hands with him.”

Dr Yee Wai Seng, the vice-chairman of the festival’s organising committee, said Mr Leong Chee Leng was not meant to be part of the group to welcome Ms Gan at the festival.

He said Mr Leong Chee Leng had approached Ms Gan out of excitement.

Mr Leong Chee Leng said Ms Gan had chatted with him during the event. He added that after the handshaking incident blew up online, she met him to apologise in person.

“We talked it out and everything is okay. I didn’t take the incident to heart,” said Mr Leong.

The member of the lion dance troupe who shot the video had uploaded it on Facebook as a record of the event, but did not know who later spliced and circulated the handshake portion.

Mr Edward Leong, who is president of the Singapore Poon Yue Association, said: “We are very disturbed and concerned that the uploaded videos (on social media) were with bad intentions.”

Dr Yee added in Mandarin: “We hope netizens can rationally think about this incident and not view this from a single-sided perspective, or embellish details and cause division.

“Hopefully, we can put this misunderstanding to rest and move forward.”

https://www.straitstimes.com/singap...ideo-to-clear-the-air-over-handshake-incident
 

qhong61

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2015
Messages
72,711
Reaction score
12,116
A cultural group has released footage to clear the air over a handshake incident that led to criticism online of Minister of State for Foreign Affairs and Trade and Industry Gan Siow Huang.

Kwong Wai Siew Peck San Theng said they had invited Ms Gan for a Cantonese cultural festival held at Peck San Theng in Bishan Lane on May 17.

Representatives of the 155-year-old cultural institution, which is managed by 16 Cantonese clan associations, were waiting to greet her when she arrived alone.

The footage shows her alighting from the car, with a mobile phone in her right hand. She then slips the phone into her rear right trousers pocket as representatives of the group approach her.

Among those who extended their hand was Mr Leong Chee Leng.

The 72-year-old is a member of the Kong Chow Wui Koon lion dance troupe, which was scheduled to perform at the Cantonese cultural festival.

Mr Leong Chee Leng can be seen extending his hand to greet her, but Ms Gan is also approached by Mr Edward Leong, the chairman of the cultural festival’s organising committee.

After shaking hands with Mr Edward Leong, Ms Gan takes Mr Leong Chee Leng’s hand, and then proceeds to shake the hands of several others gathered at the carpark.

The footage was shown at a press conference held by the cultural institution on June 13 at Peck San Theng.

Mr Leong Chee Leng, who was at the press conference, said he noticed that Ms Gan was momentarily distracted by her mobile phone and when somebody else approached her, but did eventually shake his hand.

He said in Mandarin: “(Ms Gan) is really very polite. It’s not like what you imagine from the video. Why do netizens want to attack me and the minister?”

Ms Gan had on June 8 apologised after a video, shot by somebody in the lion dance troupe, made the rounds on social media.

Ms Gan, who is the MP for Marymount SMC, told The Straits Times that it was her first visit to Peck San Theng, and she was overwhelmed by the group that went to greet her.

“When I got out of the car, I was trying to identify the host of Peck San Theng and shake hands with the host first,” she said.

“I was also a little overwhelmed by the big group that received me when I got out of my car. I sincerely apologise to the man in the red shirt for the delay in shaking hands with him.”

Dr Yee Wai Seng, the vice-chairman of the festival’s organising committee, said Mr Leong Chee Leng was not meant to be part of the group to welcome Ms Gan at the festival.

He said Mr Leong Chee Leng had approached Ms Gan out of excitement.

Mr Leong Chee Leng said Ms Gan had chatted with him during the event. He added that after the handshaking incident blew up online, she met him to apologise in person.

“We talked it out and everything is okay. I didn’t take the incident to heart,” said Mr Leong.

The member of the lion dance troupe who shot the video had uploaded it on Facebook as a record of the event, but did not know who later spliced and circulated the handshake portion.

Mr Edward Leong, who is president of the Singapore Poon Yue Association, said: “We are very disturbed and concerned that the uploaded videos (on social media) were with bad intentions.”

Dr Yee added in Mandarin: “We hope netizens can rationally think about this incident and not view this from a single-sided perspective, or embellish details and cause division.

“Hopefully, we can put this misunderstanding to rest and move forward.”

https://www.straitstimes.com/singap...ideo-to-clear-the-air-over-handshake-incident
So is Mr Leong not Mr Chan.
72yo not 78yo.
 

Lance321

Supremacy Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2006
Messages
6,254
Reaction score
2,258
Welp, even the guy in red said it wasn't big deal and to stop attacking him and the minister. Can close this thread. The end. Go find something else to complain about. Haha...
 

cesc-ark

Master Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2007
Messages
3,345
Reaction score
626
why need to explain so much over a non-issue?
just make it seems like its a damn big issue lol..
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts.

Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards, Terms of Service and Member T&Cs for more information.
Top