[Official] Home Automation Thread

MaoZeDuo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2012
Messages
9,806
Reaction score
66
U got picture of the new packaging?

2afuKSK.jpg

 

bullfrog

Banned
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
18,188
Reaction score
1,152
If a certified electrician gets your switches burnt, then maybe there are issues.
The thing i am trying to bring across is that smart switches have processors (just like a computer) installing 10 of them is like installing several processors in your home; connected to a live wire.

Some things are better to get professionals to do. it is not as simple as plugging 2 wires into a switch anymore.

Sorry, but i also I don't quite understand why this is so different.

The certified electricians i have encountered treat smart switches like regular light switches. They just install it like how they would with any other 'dumb' light switch.

They don't care and don't even know how to configure it.

Only difference is, for my place, i told him to pull neutral wires to all my switch points. I showed him the aqara light switch, told him to just connect the neutral wire into it's respective slot, and off he went to do it.

When i checked my place the following day, the light switches were installed and they worked.

It was almost a month after i moved in before i started configuring them. :s13:



Posted from PCWX using Me dic stinks
 

AsusEpoxy

Master Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
3,438
Reaction score
23
If a certified electrician gets your switches burnt, then maybe there are issues.
The thing i am trying to bring across is that smart switches have processors (just like a computer) installing 10 of them is like installing several processors in your home; connected to a live wire.

Some things are better to get professionals to do. it is not as simple as plugging 2 wires into a switch anymore.


The point that we are trying to put across is that for something as simple as 2 wires, the electrician is not gonna do it any different from a layman.
Look i get it, u have a business in such home automation stuff and trying to protect your turf. Fact is the aqara non neutrals are failing. Other non neutrals from broadlink aren't. At least not the same rate. Its not a matter of installation professionalism, its a QC issue.

Also, the switches fail a few MONTHS after installation. In most use case scenarios, they were used well UNDER spec. I have doubts any electrician will guarantee their work quality for burnt switch a few months after installation because electricity use in any environment is DYNAMIC and changing.

The Aqara Neutrals have significantly better survival rates than the Non Neutrals. In your words they are all mini computers connected to the live wire, how come the non neutrals have such a much higher failure rate?

1 of the Xiaomi Importers (PassionGadgets iirc) gave warranty on all their products they brought in except the Aqara Non Neutral. That was how bad it was. They probably were experiencing returns like nobody's business.

Anything that uses electricity needs to be connected to a live circuit.
Electricity needs to be understood, respected, not to be feared.

You referred to your own sampling size , why not refer to searches on here and and MI forums as well? If even Aqara admits there is an improved version, that also means they reworked it, meaning there was really something wrong in the 1st place right?
 
Last edited:

medscy

Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2006
Messages
497
Reaction score
5
Hi all, I'm thinking of adding a door sensor to detect any unauthorized entering to my weekend home. Currently using broadlink and whole house is fitted with RF switch/lights.

Should I use broadlink S2 or Xiaomi hub+sensor? Or any other recommendations?

Sent from HUAWEI BLA-L29 using GAGT
The question for you will be... why do you want to invest in a 2nd ecosystem that may lead to interoperability issues down the road? What is the driver that leads you to go for Zigbee instead of RF?
 

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
@bullfrog, becos in sg, electrican really dun care, there is no requirement for them to be re-train / upgrade regularly too keep their cert. unlike other 1st world countries, electricians can be graded. home owners only look for electricians w automation experience or choose products with strong local support

---------------------------------------------------------------


becos it is electronic switch>>

1) some electronic switch cannot be wired to a latch on device, which may explain why aqara non-neu get burnt out
2) There is a wattage limit to the devices
3) There is a total max device wired to the loop
item 3, may not have relation to item 2. there is only so much "ram" the electronic can process, once u exceed the max device in a loop, it will over work and burnt out due to thermal overload. But i supposed the aqara due to its low price range, do not have a "cct" protection built onto it. so it dies quick. it can also be part of XM marketing strategy. too many factors

As abv, thats generic speculation, without having to open up aqara to have a look.

and as to why u may need electrican, if ur home have certian age, and its not 1st home owner, the previous owner may have been very funky w the connections. when electrican open up, they can tell and advise u can or not do it.

then there is insurance issue also. and please, i have seen enough DIY, their cables not long enough, suka suka connect cables w cables...and tape them up and become v happy
 
Last edited:

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
The point that we are trying to put across is that for something as simple as 2 wires, the electrician is not gonna do it any different from a layman.
Look i get it, u have a business in such home automation stuff and trying to protect your turf. Fact is the aqara non neutrals are failing. Other non neutrals from broadlink aren't. At least not the same rate. Its not a matter of installation professionalism, its a QC issue.
i dun think thats what domo_cat mean. He prolly may have not have articulate it precise enough.

i am located in singapore but moi support global market. which is why i sorta get where
domo coming from.

I cannot comment on whats wrong on aqara without opening it up for test
 
Last edited:

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
The question for you will be... why do you want to invest in a 2nd ecosystem that may lead to interoperability issues down the road? What is the driver that leads you to go for Zigbee instead of RF?
tag on to ur post

Most gateways are equip with zigbee or tcp/ip modbus.

Noise with RF is louder, and soemtimes maybe receive signal, it is mostly 1 way comm mode as compare to ZB where it will ping for a reply

RF is cheap, and good for small room
 
Last edited:

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
If a certified electrician gets your switches burnt, then maybe there are issues.
The thing i am trying to bring across is that smart switches have processors (just like a computer) installing 10 of them is like installing several processors in your home; connected to a live wire.

Some things are better to get professionals to do. it is not as simple as plugging 2 wires into a switch anymore.
professional yes, in this context, it should be a professional who is an electrician and familiar with the product and / or automation knowledge
 

AsusEpoxy

Master Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
3,438
Reaction score
23
professional yes, in this context, it should be a professional who is an electrician and familiar with the product and / or automation knowledge

yes i agree... and the sad fact is that many electricians i meet aren't updated with smart home automation knowledge.

Many of them are adamant there is no reason to add neutral to light switches at all. They simply give you blank looks and think you have mixed up a normal power point with light switch point.
 

AsusEpoxy

Master Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
3,438
Reaction score
23
i dun think thats what domo_cat mean. He prolly may have not have articulate it precise enough.

i am located in singapore but moi support global market. which is why i sorta get where
domo coming from.

I cannot comment on whats wrong on aqara without opening it up for test

if u like, i can pass you some of mine for a post mortem. I opened up 1 before. no burnt marks as can be seen with the naked eye. :s13:
 

MaoZeDuo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2012
Messages
9,806
Reaction score
66
yes i agree... and the sad fact is that many electricians i meet aren't updated with smart home automation knowledge.

Many of them are adamant there is no reason to add neutral to light switches at all. They simply give you blank looks and think you have mixed up a normal power point with light switch point.

Yes I received the same blank look but its the other way round as they usually install with neutral wiring for home automation companies.. so when i told them mine dont need (the non neutral aqara)... they say mine is not a smart switch
 

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
if u like, i can pass you some of mine for a post mortem. I opened up 1 before. no burnt marks as can be seen with the naked eye. :s13:
mai la. their products and my products ...1 earth vs 1universe

my end we deal with premium pricing. but premium pricing means, there is technical support to detect issues before consumers finds out
 

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
yes i agree... and the sad fact is that many electricians i meet aren't updated with smart home automation knowledge.

Many of them are adamant there is no reason to add neutral to light switches at all. They simply give you blank looks and think you have mixed up a normal power point with light switch point.
better term than neutral is "control cable"

that " neutral" is send signal or dry contact pulse maybe they will understand more
 

pajamasguy

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 28, 2007
Messages
83
Reaction score
0
Well gentlemen, I've also met with the same fate lately. 3 of my switches had failed (out of 13). One year of usage so far. The switches production date are all late 2017. I know cause I noted down everything. So the claim that there was a bad batch in 2018 - well that better not be the case cause mine are 2017 and they had better fix the problem in 2018 batches. I also confirmed this with Lumi - they said there was a bad batch. I hope that is true.

As for the BS that you need to be a qualified electrician to install this, well thats not the reason why they are failing, not because of some bad job done. As long as you had tighten down the screws properly, you are good to go. Theres nothing more simpler than how a switch works. Anything more, then its just somebody wanting to take your money by claiming otherwise.

And the load has nothing to do with it either. 800 watts is a lot of load that it can handle. My whole house lighting don't even exceed 500 watts. I think most of us are using LED lights nowadays. It's also not about where the wire is looping to or how many bulbs it is connected to and all that BS.

They failed because the switches are bad, period. Whether all are bad or some are bad - we don't know. I like to believe that only some are bad over a short period of time due to bad components. One thing I am certain - its not because of an external factor.
 

pustefix

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
537
Reaction score
10
Based on my experience and the feedback from other users here, I have advised my colleagues not to get the non-neutral Aqara wall switch. However I am also not 100% convinced that the neutral ones are more reliable. This is because the number of users with non-neutral switch far outweighs the number with neutral switch. If more users use the neutral ones, we may see higher failure rate as well.
 

SaLvAtoOo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2000
Messages
5,815
Reaction score
17
Based on my experience and the feedback from other users here, I have advised my colleagues not to get the non-neutral Aqara wall switch. However I am also not 100% convinced that the neutral ones are more reliable. This is because the number of users with non-neutral switch far outweighs the number with neutral switch. If more users use the neutral ones, we may see higher failure rate as well.


should count the total number of switches instead of ppl... in my house alone, i have 12 neutral switches..... so far so good *touch wood*

before this, they were all non-neutral and i have wasted too much time and money until i lost count on how many had spoilt....
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top