[Official] Home Automation Thread

SaLvAtoOo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2000
Messages
5,815
Reaction score
17
If a certified electrician gets your switches burnt, then maybe there are issues.
The thing i am trying to bring across is that smart switches have processors (just like a computer) installing 10 of them is like installing several processors in your home; connected to a live wire.

Some things are better to get professionals to do. it is not as simple as plugging 2 wires into a switch anymore.

guys, dont need to debate.. if you are not comfortable or no experience, just get an electrician to do.

For tech savvy ppl, there's certainly no issue connecting / changing the switch yourself.

it doesnt mean that using a qualified electrician, electrical fire wont take place right?

and btw, smart switch are no diff than normal switch.. it just has additional circuit which contain the micro-controllers to control the operation of the AC switches.
 

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
how to diy if the original switch no neutral wire?
use a xbee gateway, bluetooth controlled products and there is alot of other home use brand in the market that is way better than aqara, just that price isnt.
 
Last edited:

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
diy pull the neutral cable? haha.. tats wat i did...
that too.

but that part, we ended up hire a foreign worker. he is licenced in sg tho. just that its cheaper for him to source the cable:s13: plus we edy knew what had to be done all we needed was a lic elect worker, again for insurance sake
we basically change out >75% the cabling including telecom cable. We had to do it by batches, room by room, while moved in. even the whole DB plus its breakers was makeover

we as in there are 2 elect engineers at home
 
Last edited:

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
Well gentlemen, I've also met with the same fate lately. 3 of my switches had failed (out of 13). One year of usage so far. The switches production date are all late 2017. I know cause I noted down everything. So the claim that there was a bad batch in 2018 - well that better not be the case cause mine are 2017 and they had better fix the problem in 2018 batches. I also confirmed this with Lumi - they said there was a bad batch. I hope that is true.

As for the BS that you need to be a qualified electrician to install this, well thats not the reason why they are failing, not because of some bad job done. As long as you had tighten down the screws properly, you are good to go. Theres nothing more simpler than how a switch works. Anything more, then its just somebody wanting to take your money by claiming otherwise.

And the load has nothing to do with it either. 800 watts is a lot of load that it can handle. My whole house lighting don't even exceed 500 watts. I think most of us are using LED lights nowadays. It's also not about where the wire is looping to or how many bulbs it is connected to and all that BS.

They failed because the switches are bad, period. Whether all are bad or some are bad - we don't know. I like to believe that only some are bad over a short period of time due to bad components. One thing I am certain - its not because of an external factor.
or their specs is not what it says it is

there is a very high chance that its not R&D by xiaomi, and they took it from OEM and re-label it. as we know OEM mass sell to other home automation band
 

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
guys, dont need to debate.. if you are not comfortable or no experience, just get an electrician to do.

For tech savvy ppl, there's certainly no issue connecting / changing the switch yourself.

it doesnt mean that using a qualified electrician, electrical fire wont take place right?

and btw, smart switch are no diff than normal switch.. it just has additional circuit which contain the micro-controllers to control the operation of the AC switches.
depends how basic is the automation switches are.

if one is looking at premium products, which are usually installed in those 3-5 million condominium or 5* hotels, its complex. I had to take total of 7 days 8-5pm course and require to have basic knowledge of scripting, and i am not even an installer.

yes going back to this thread, and aqara switches. its basic, i said the abv, so that readers are informed that, it can get complicated dependent on what sort of end services they sought in a home automation; altho just a sample size end users may want complex switch.


additional:

LOL i shall take back some of my words, i din know aqara switch is this over price!! wow they tag their price jus 10-20% lesser than the premium products i am aware of

-- period no more on electrican or not
 
Last edited:

SaLvAtoOo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2000
Messages
5,815
Reaction score
17
did you happen to take pics of how you did that? can't find any installation video for neutral switch online

there's several ways to do it...
if your DB box is near, you can just pull a neutral wire from your DB box.
if not, the simplest way is to pull from your lights. Your lights confirm have neutral.
Otherwise, you can also pull from the nearby 3-pin socket.

you also need to know how to pull the cable.. for eg, exposed trunking is the simplest... or hidden in the wall and you have to use "fishing" cables... or false ceiling which you may need to saw open and put back afterwards.. it really depends on your current set-up...
 
Last edited:

tian800

Junior Member
Joined
May 7, 2018
Messages
61
Reaction score
3
So anyone still experienced any failed switch using the new batch (new packaging) of Aqara switches?
 

Elon Jobs

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2018
Messages
2,434
Reaction score
1,261
llv9Wer.jpg

SQgXv9S.jpg


Broadlink SP2 $16.20 after 20% discount inclusive of shipping. 2 hours left.

https://shopee.sg/longtong.sg/1415349653
 

ralfale

Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
5,451
Reaction score
8
I was eyeing somfy motors for my curtains too but they don't seem to be compatible with alexa or Google home.

Their asian region mylink is discontinued as connexoon replaces it. However i read on somfy support site they have no plans to have connexoon work with alexa.

After researching deeper into alternate curtain motors, i saw xiaomi has released a zigbee enabled curtain motor!

The community support on smarthings was also successful in getting smarthings to work with it. This also means Alexa should be able to control that motor via smartthings.

Since i have a smartthings hub already, i just ordered a xiaomi motor from AliExpress.
I will try to see if my hub can talk to it.

My next hurdle, after confirming the motor, smarthings and alexa work together, is getting the curtain rails. However that doesn't seem to be too difficult a problem. We can also buy the rails from Ali express. Just need to give them the lengths we need.

Anyway, if this solution works, i'll be able to have motorised curtains that alexa can control at a fraction of the cost of a somfy motor.

Too bad somfy doesn't want to support alexa. They lost one customer here as i would not have bothered researching into other motors if they had.

Any further development how to link connexoon to alexa?
 

medscy

Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2006
Messages
497
Reaction score
5
i cannot find a use for smart plug tbh.. if i need light i rather get yeelight. if other devices most of them can't be turned on with just power

You can use this to switch off any standing fan which does not have IR control or even switch on rice cooker so that you can have timely hot rice when reaching home.

The only gripe will be how to integrate with any existing system if you are running Broadlink... 😂... I don't want to run hassio or openhab to clock more electricity
 

SaLvAtoOo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2000
Messages
5,815
Reaction score
17
You can use this to switch off any standing fan which does not have IR control or even switch on rice cooker so that you can have timely hot rice when reaching home.

The only gripe will be how to integrate with any existing system if you are running Broadlink... 😂... I don't want to run hassio or openhab to clock more electricity

hassio on rpi wont consume alot of electricity.... =D

if you already have synology, can even run HA on docker.
 

SaLvAtoOo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2000
Messages
5,815
Reaction score
17
i cannot find a use for smart plug tbh.. if i need light i rather get yeelight. if other devices most of them can't be turned on with just power

true to a certain extend... for eg my KDK fan.. even if i on the power, i still need another IR blaster to send the IR signal to turn on the fan. Turning on power alone is not enough...
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top