[Official] Home Automation Thread

seianko

Suspended
Joined
Jan 14, 2004
Messages
74,705
Reaction score
43
no offense... may i ask... what's the diff between using a paper qualified electrician to screw the live wire into the socket.... VS a non qualified electrician to screw the live wire into the socket?

probably it's like what u mentioned, the newer batch with the new packaging may b more reliable... dont tink it has anything to do with electrician.
paper qualify knows what they are doing when dealing with old retrofit homes with aged cabling. That paper not easy to get also. with new regulation in place, i no longer qualified to collect it.

and if u have insurance for home, suay suay u need to claim, good luck if u cannot prove the installation is sign off by qualified. even if that say i.e fire has nth to do with the installation.

I am not saying u do not know what u are doing, i am referring to general public, esp i have seen a fair share of funky installation leaves me jaw drop, and yet the owners very proud of their achievements. i can only smile and walk away from buying the unit
 
Last edited:

AsusEpoxy

Master Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
3,438
Reaction score
23
Sure hope its improved and not just a packaging refresh. I have had 6 switches died on me already and that's alot of money wasted to be honest.

Thank you. Sharing the pic sent to me


gi6SzpP.jpg



Posted from PCWX using Me dic stinks
 

sellun

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2013
Messages
1,487
Reaction score
51
Hi all, I'm thinking of adding a door sensor to detect any unauthorized entering to my weekend home. Currently using broadlink and whole house is fitted with RF switch/lights.

Should I use broadlink S2 or Xiaomi hub+sensor? Or any other recommendations?

Sent from HUAWEI BLA-L29 using GAGT
 

AsusEpoxy

Master Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
3,438
Reaction score
23
hmmm did you install the switches on your own?

yes i did. I am not an electrician, but cases of these non neutral switches failing have been well documented.

Even the single rocker switchs fail. 2 wires, L and L1 also can fail. you do not need to be electrician to put in 2 correctly labelled wires right?
 

AsusEpoxy

Master Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
3,438
Reaction score
23
No neutral! bring neutral to switch need $, fug this ****. bring the switch to the neutral!

Ok guys, so the non neutral Aqara switches have been dying on me one by one.
Electrician quoted me $2200 to rewire neutral cables to the switches because the cabling are hidden in the cornices and false ceilings :eek:

I pondered about it and decided to go about it in another way. Since the light fittings (where the wires are connected to the light bulbs) have neutral, why can't i

1. close up the electrical circuit where my existing switches are(join the wires up), cover up with a type 86mm blank panel.
2. Introduce the Xiaomi Zigbee Socket switch between the lights and its wiring.
3. Configure a Aqara Wireless 2 rocker switch and stick it on the closed up panel.

This will achieve light control with some pros and cons. Essentially this is still the same electrical circuit, just that the switch is relocated to another part of the circuit. It is safer too because the proposed switch has neutral and earth and a higher rated power.


Pros:

1. The Zigbee Socket switch is rated for 1500w iirc and has neutral. It also has energy consumption monitoring unlike the non neutral ones
2. Stability. No more non neutral Aqara switch woes.
3. Cheaper than the non neutral Aqara switches.


Cons:
1. resetting the switch need you to climb up to your light fixture to take it out and do so.
2. Wireless rocker switch requires battery change every 1 to 2years.
3. The slight lag when using a wireless switch.
4. Suitable for recess lighting where u can have places to hide the switch.
5. Also not suitable for lighting groups where 1 switch is to control multiple lights in a group (Unless u are able to isolate the point where the group is connected)


I tried it and it works!!! YOSH!


:s13:
 
Last edited:

pustefix

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
537
Reaction score
10
1. close up the electrical circuit where my existing switches are(join the wires up), cover up with a type 86mm blank panel.
2. Introduce the Xiaomi Zigbee Socket switch between the lights and its wiring.
3. Configure a Aqara Wireless 2 rocker switch and stick it on the closed up panel.

Interesting way to solve this problem! You do not have to cover up with blank 86mm panel, you can drill 2 holes on the Aqara wireless switch and mount it directly on the 86mm bracket (use flat screwdriver to open up the switch and you will see the position of the holes). I also notice that the Xiaomi wall switch has a noticeable click sound, so after you click on the wireless switch, you will hear a click sound at the light before it turns on/off?
 
Last edited:

AsusEpoxy

Master Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
3,438
Reaction score
23
Interesting way to solve this problem! You do not have to cover up with blank 86mm panel, you can drill 2 holes on the Aqara wireless switch and mount it directly on the 86mm bracket (use flat screwdriver to open up the switch and you will see the position of the holes). I also notice that the Xiaomi wall switch has a noticeable click sound, so after you click on the wireless switch, you will hear a click sound at the light before it turns on/off?

The click sound is generated by the connected switch instead, but since it is hidden up in the false ceiling, you can barely hear it unless u are watching out for it.
 

bullfrog

Banned
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
18,188
Reaction score
1,152
Ok guys, so the non neutral Aqara switches have been dying on me one by one.
Electrician quoted me $2200 to rewire neutral cables to the switches because the cabling are hidden in the cornices and false ceilings
:eek:

I pondered about it and decided to go about it in another way. Since the light fittings (where the wires are connected to the light bulbs) have neutral, why can't i

1. close up the electrical circuit where my existing switches are(join the wires up), cover up with a type 86mm blank panel.
2. Introduce the Xiaomi Zigbee Socket switch between the lights and its wiring.
3. Configure a Aqara Wireless 2 rocker switch and stick it on the closed up panel.

This will achieve light control with some pros and cons. Essentially this is still the same electrical circuit, just that the switch is relocated to another part of the circuit. It is safer too because the proposed switch has neutral and earth and a higher rated power.


Pros:

1. The Zigbee Socket switch is rated for 1500w iirc and has neutral. It also has energy consumption monitoring unlike the non neutral ones
2. Stability. No more non neutral Aqara switch woes.
3. Cheaper than the non neutral Aqara switches.


Cons:
1. resetting the switch need you to climb up to your light fixture to take it out and do so.
2. Wireless rocker switch requires battery change every 1 to 2years.
3. The slight lag when using a wireless switch.
4. Suitable for recess lighting where u can have places to hide the switch.
5. Also not suitable for lighting groups where 1 switch is to control multiple lights in a group (Unless u are able to isolate the point where the group is connected)


I tried it and it works!!! YOSH!



:s13:

Thats a cost effective way. Also a very neat solution. :)

But if u hide the neutral aqara switch *inside* the recess ceiling, if for some reason the switch catches fire, how will you know, since its not visible? Asking cos there are pictures of burnt (non-neutral) aqara switches circulating around and those really had me worried.




Posted from PCWX using Me dic stinks
 

AsusEpoxy

Master Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2003
Messages
3,438
Reaction score
23
Thats a cost effective way. Also a very neat solution. :)

But if u hide the neutral aqara switch *inside* the recess ceiling, if for some reason the switch catches fire, how will you know, since its not visible? Asking cos there are pictures of burnt (non-neutral) aqara switches circulating around and those really had me worried.




Posted from PCWX using Me dic stinks

yo bro, i supposed i can isolate it in a small styrofoam box of sand...but thats overkill. As the switch is actually rated for normal mains instead of lighting mains, being used for lighting shouldn't stress it at all.

I wonder if can add notification in mi home if it goes offline. That can be a warning thing.
 

bullfrog

Banned
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
18,188
Reaction score
1,152
yo bro, i supposed i can isolate it in a small styrofoam box of sand...but thats overkill. As the switch is actually rated for normal mains instead of lighting mains, being used for lighting shouldn't stress it at all.

I wonder if can add notification in mi home if it goes offline. That can be a warning thing.

The sandbox solution is definitely an over kill!

Maybe its okay. So far, nobody has reported their neutral aqara switches getting burnt. I guess i got paranoid after seeing pics of burnt ( non-neutral) aqara switches.

Haha, I even installed z-wave smoke detectors in my house (connected to my smarthings) just in case. But thats also in the interest of a smarter home la :s13:



Posted from PCWX using Me dic stinks
 

domo_Cat

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2018
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
yes i did. I am not an electrician, but cases of these non neutral switches failing have been well documented.

Even the single rocker switchs fail. 2 wires, L and L1 also can fail. you do not need to be electrician to put in 2 correctly labelled wires right?

Hmmm may i know who you purchased the switches from?
 

domo_Cat

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2018
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
The sandbox solution is definitely an over kill!

Maybe its okay. So far, nobody has reported their neutral aqara switches getting burnt. I guess i got paranoid after seeing pics of burnt ( non-neutral) aqara switches.

Haha, I even installed z-wave smoke detectors in my house (connected to my smarthings) just in case. But thats also in the interest of a smarter home la :s13:



Posted from PCWX using Me dic stinks

If a certified electrician gets your switches burnt, then maybe there are issues.
The thing i am trying to bring across is that smart switches have processors (just like a computer) installing 10 of them is like installing several processors in your home; connected to a live wire.

Some things are better to get professionals to do. it is not as simple as plugging 2 wires into a switch anymore.
 

MaoZeDuo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2012
Messages
9,806
Reaction score
66
If a certified electrician gets your switches burnt, then maybe there are issues.
The thing i am trying to bring across is that smart switches have processors (just like a computer) installing 10 of them is like installing several processors in your home; connected to a live wire.

Some things are better to get professionals to do. it is not as simple as plugging 2 wires into a switch anymore.

Pls share more
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top