[Official] Home Automation Thread

plustwo

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2009
Messages
12,689
Reaction score
580
i give up on ha.. working fine with openhab. even better, can use the free cloud to link with google assistant. goodbye ha
 

pig@@gie

Junior Member
Joined
Jul 12, 2009
Messages
81
Reaction score
0
Appreciate ur lengthy reply, clear my doubt, thanks!!
neutral point is a star configuration, incoming down all down
and then depend how he does the single nodal neutral, as in where he located it.
cons, any issues, u hv a hard time troubleshooting which one uplorry. Most establishments would go for this mode. #cheaper,better, faster
(better as in is for installer pov, save trouble, earn more money)>> in ur case, ur electrician trying to save u $

individual meaning, each device will have a neutral cable to run back to the mains.
Cons, cost more
Pros, u know which one is down from layman pov. For some appliances, it is recommended practice

For old retrofit homes, i will say go for separate node (point/jn box)of neutral. so that u know when it goes down, u know its the new one or old one. BUT there can be huge difficulty in installation -- space


//one answer per day quota is up :D
 

domo_Cat

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2018
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
Aqara Neutral Wire

Hi all, i've read how Aqara non-neutral switches are failing on this forum.

On my end i have a slightly different experience. My non-neutral wire Aqara switches have been working well since 2 years ago. We have also assisted several homes in implementing smart home solutions using Aqara non-neutral switches and so far only 1 case of Aqara non neutral switch failing (this is because the client insisted on using his/her own electricians). Afterwhich, we insist that all aqara smart switches have to be installed by our own electricians. Since then, all switches installed have been working fine.

What i understand from talking to the Aqara suppliers & some of the electricians who installs smart switches is that there is a batch released in 2018 that is unstable. Ever since Aqara has launched a new version of smart switch (both neutral and non-neutral version) with a very different packaging.

Would like to clarify that smart switches are each a computer on its own and has to be managed by electricians who have experience with smart switches. the end result of a smart switch is dependent on several variables which may or may not be caused by the device itself.

Another variable is that there are a counterfeit switches online. Hence it is important to only purchase smart switches from reliable sources.

Hope this information help anyone out there who is seeking to implement affordable smart home solutions in their homes. Regardless, implementing smart home should be a learning journey for everyone :)
 

SaLvAtoOo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2000
Messages
5,815
Reaction score
17
Hi all, i've read how Aqara non-neutral switches are failing on this forum.

On my end i have a slightly different experience. My non-neutral wire Aqara switches have been working well since 2 years ago. We have also assisted several homes in implementing smart home solutions using Aqara non-neutral switches and so far only 1 case of Aqara non neutral switch failing (this is because the client insisted on using his/her own electricians). Afterwhich, we insist that all aqara smart switches have to be installed by our own electricians. Since then, all switches installed have been working fine.

What i understand from talking to the Aqara suppliers & some of the electricians who installs smart switches is that there is a batch released in 2018 that is unstable. Ever since Aqara has launched a new version of smart switch (both neutral and non-neutral version) with a very different packaging.

Would like to clarify that smart switches are each a computer on its own and has to be managed by electricians who have experience with smart switches. the end result of a smart switch is dependent on several variables which may or may not be caused by the device itself.

Another variable is that there are a counterfeit switches online. Hence it is important to only purchase smart switches from reliable sources.

Hope this information help anyone out there who is seeking to implement affordable smart home solutions in their homes. Regardless, implementing smart home should be a learning journey for everyone :)

no offense... may i ask... what's the diff between using a paper qualified electrician to screw the live wire into the socket.... VS a non qualified electrician to screw the live wire into the socket?

probably it's like what u mentioned, the newer batch with the new packaging may b more reliable... dont tink it has anything to do with electrician.
 

bullfrog

Banned
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
18,188
Reaction score
1,152
What i understand from talking to the Aqara suppliers & some of the electricians who installs smart switches is that there is a batch released in 2018 that is unstable. Ever since Aqara has launched a new version of smart switch (both neutral and non-neutral version) with a very different packaging.

Can GPGT the new packaging so we know what to look out for? Also where to buy?

Posted from PCWX using Me dic stinks
 

domo_Cat

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2018
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
no offense... may i ask... what's the diff between using a paper qualified electrician to screw the live wire into the socket.... VS a non qualified electrician to screw the live wire into the socket?

probably it's like what u mentioned, the newer batch with the new packaging may b more reliable... dont tink it has anything to do with electrician.


TBH, i don't really have a lot of experience with other electricians. so i can't comment. Just sharing my observations.

If you prefer, you may use your preferred electricians to install the smart switches.
 

SaLvAtoOo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2000
Messages
5,815
Reaction score
17
TBH, i don't really have a lot of experience with other electricians. so i can't comment. Just sharing my observations.

If you prefer, you may use your preferred electricians to install the smart switches.

i install myself.. hehe.. but the first batch of non-neutral switch really problematic... the problem with the non-neutral is the amount of load it can take.

800W vs 2500W

Yes, typically, a lamp doesn't use 800w. However, the light point may not be a dedicated light point from the breaker.... it may be in parallel connection with several lamps or even switch that some ppl use to power appliances.

ANyway, i changed all of my switches to neutral and have no problem thus far....

no comments on the new batch of non-neutral aqara switches tho..
 

domo_Cat

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2018
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
Can GPGT the new packaging so we know what to look out for? Also where to buy?

Posted from PCWX using Me dic stinks

Cant post links due to insufficient post counts. but will PM you the photos.
Best to purchase from local distributors so that if anything, you can still get warranty coverage.
 

SaLvAtoOo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2000
Messages
5,815
Reaction score
17
Cant post links due to insufficient post counts. but will PM you the photos.
Best to purchase from local distributors so that if anything, you can still get warranty coverage.

you can upload to imgr.com and post it here

Here's the diff between the old vs new packaging:
3SGjQYt.jpg
 

domo_Cat

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 22, 2018
Messages
22
Reaction score
0
800W vs 2500W

Yes, typically, a lamp doesn't use 800w. However, the light point may not be a dedicated light point from the breaker.... it may be in parallel connection with several lamps or even switch that some ppl use to power appliances.


hmmmm assuming looping is involved, each lamp may be lets say an average 15W, this means that we need 53 lights for the switch break. Maybe the house shine lights like photo studio. ke ke.

But based on what i've experienced, even if the appliance takes more than 800W the switch will just trip, won't cause the switch to just die off. Safety mechanism is there. ;)
 

bullfrog

Banned
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
Messages
18,188
Reaction score
1,152
Cant post links due to insufficient post counts. but will PM you the photos.
Best to purchase from local distributors so that if anything, you can still get warranty coverage.

Thank you. Sharing the pic sent to me


gi6SzpP.jpg



Posted from PCWX using Me dic stinks
 

MaoZeDuo

Supremacy Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2012
Messages
9,806
Reaction score
66
i install myself.. hehe.. but the first batch of non-neutral switch really problematic... the problem with the non-neutral is the amount of load it can take.

800W vs 2500W

Yes, typically, a lamp doesn't use 800w. However, the light point may not be a dedicated light point from the breaker.... it may be in parallel connection with several lamps or even switch that some ppl use to power appliances.

ANyway, i changed all of my switches to neutral and have no problem thus far....

no comments on the new batch of non-neutral aqara switches tho..

I suspect one of my light point is not dedicated to my 5x downlight... not sure how to check... cos 2 aqara switch at this point broke... now installed new version to try
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top