[Official] Home Automation Thread

Elon Jobs

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2018
Messages
2,434
Reaction score
1,261
If I may add that hassio on RPI gives you more flexibility and control and you can also integrate stuffs that run on mqtt. Furthermore, Hassio also allows you to have fanciful dashboard unlike the boring UI of Broadlink iHC or EControl.

But of course there is downside. If you are looking for voice controls like GH, it will be tougher since u might need to configure port forwarding in your network , dabble with dynamic dns and get developer accounts on Google to get it working. Alternatively, you can run on HACloud. But this is a chargeable service... Not forgetting that you also need to pay for the electricity consumed by RPI which some may argue that it is negligible. This RPI will also become a single point of failure if it is down unlike cloud providing high availability. Also note that by opening up to GH, you are also inadvertently opening up the security Pandora box. GH is a cloud service anyway.

All these depends on your needs and risk appetite. Fully agree that the cloud security of these Chinese providers is likely questionable. But more importantly, u might want to assess what is the impact to u if it HA network gets compromised. For me, I will never link up door access systems like digital lock to this and would put all these HA stuff on a different vlan.

Very objective analysis. 👍
 

gheesung

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2000
Messages
49
Reaction score
0
Hi, Can someone please educate me what is the advantage of running Home Assistant on RPi?
Currently i have a smart system of broadlink and xiaomi devices which integrates with GH.
Everything works fine here. I cant find a reason to "upgrade"

You can also consider Openhab too, the integration to Google Home is free. My Xiaomi sensors and other devices at home are controlled by Openhab.
 

gheesung

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2000
Messages
49
Reaction score
0
I also like to add that when designing the smart home, it should be designed such that when the smart hub and network failed, all the smart switches, lights and plugs should still behave normally as there is no smart hub around.
 

plustwo

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2009
Messages
12,689
Reaction score
580
i strongly suggest all of you download openhab before you buy overpriced hardware. it is way better than ha in terms of control and free to run
 

medscy

Member
Joined
Apr 17, 2006
Messages
497
Reaction score
5
Wanna check with y’all, is there an affordable device which can be integrated into Google home and broadcast a distresss call through the speaker when being activated?

Best is no need use hub.. thanks!
You can use the Broadlink S2 Hub with a RF remote and then get it to trigger GH via Ifttt. Alternatively, you can look at smart buttons like Flic for a hubless solution.. But this is quite ex.
 

tecnica

Honorary Member
Joined
Aug 20, 2002
Messages
100,583
Reaction score
0
You can use the Broadlink S2 Hub with a RF remote and then get it to trigger GH via Ifttt. Alternatively, you can look at smart buttons like Flic for a hubless solution.. But this is quite ex.

I think I will get a separate button and alarm system cos it can be brought overseas to use.. I.e when we stay in hotel but in different rooms.. saw some on Amazon and Lazada but not sure which is good..
 

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398
Started migrating some of my Xiaomi sensors over to Zigbee2mqtt.

Benefits of Zigbee2mqtt:
  • Cheaper ( less than S$10)
  • One hub for multiple ecosystems like Philips Hue, Xiaomi, Sengled, Sylvania, Ikea Tradfri etc
  • Hub will not connect to China or cloud at will
  • Ability to use all zigbee routers in the same network(for wider network range)
  • Sometimes better (than manufacturer's) support for some devices
  • Support for some devices that are otherwise unsupported.

Currently 191 devices are supported from 39 different vendors..

Integrates well with HA and MQTT discovery too.
 

ksapple

High Supremacy Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2012
Messages
27,532
Reaction score
4,897
Any have echo dot wan to trade with google home mini??

My house is all echo some one gave me a google home soo looking to swap it
 

plustwo

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2009
Messages
12,689
Reaction score
580
Started migrating some of my Xiaomi sensors over to Zigbee2mqtt.

Benefits of Zigbee2mqtt:
  • Cheaper ( less than S$10)
  • One hub for multiple ecosystems like Philips Hue, Xiaomi, Sengled, Sylvania, Ikea Tradfri etc
  • Hub will not connect to China or cloud at will
  • Ability to use all zigbee routers in the same network(for wider network range)
  • Sometimes better (than manufacturer's) support for some devices
  • Support for some devices that are otherwise unsupported.

Currently 191 devices are supported from 39 different vendors..

Integrates well with HA and MQTT discovery too.
can just buy conbee.. ha is so backward.. switch to openhab better
 

pustefix

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
537
Reaction score
10
Does it work well with Aqara wall switches? Currently my Xiaomi Gateway will sort of disconnect a few hours daily. The symptom is that in HA log will get "Cannot connect to Gateway" and the switch will not be able to turn on/off with MiHome app or HA. The sensors are still working though, i.e. motion is still detected but light will not turn on.

Started migrating some of my Xiaomi sensors over to Zigbee2mqtt.

Benefits of Zigbee2mqtt:
  • Cheaper ( less than S$10)
  • One hub for multiple ecosystems like Philips Hue, Xiaomi, Sengled, Sylvania, Ikea Tradfri etc
  • Hub will not connect to China or cloud at will
  • Ability to use all zigbee routers in the same network(for wider network range)
  • Sometimes better (than manufacturer's) support for some devices
  • Support for some devices that are otherwise unsupported.

Currently 191 devices are supported from 39 different vendors..

Integrates well with HA and MQTT discovery too.
 

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398
Does it work well with Aqara wall switches? Currently my Xiaomi Gateway will sort of disconnect a few hours daily. The symptom is that in HA log will get "Cannot connect to Gateway" and the switch will not be able to turn on/off with MiHome app or HA. The sensors are still working though, i.e. motion is still detected but light will not turn on.

1. There's a fix for the Xiaomi gateway issue.

2. Sorry I don't use Aqara wall switches but the list of supported devices has QBKG12LM and QBKG11LM which has power measurement so I presume this is the neutral version.
 

zoneguard

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 2, 2000
Messages
1,957
Reaction score
398
can just buy conbee.. ha is so backward.. switch to openhab better

Well, deCONZ is supported in HA as well. My own experience of HA is positive:
  • Big active community of users and developers. Count the Youtubers famous in the home automation circle among them. This is important not just for support when you encounter issues but also to show you the possibilities of what can be achieved. Reddit and HA forum are all very active.
  • Versatile. Any device with REST/HTTP/MQTT exposed can be integrated. Even when these don't exist, you can find native support. Example: Broadlink and TP-Link devices which I personally use.
  • Python core. An example of this benefit will be the JupyterLab used by data scientists.
 

plustwo

Arch-Supremacy Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2009
Messages
12,689
Reaction score
580
Care to share why ha is more backward compared to openhab?
the control you have in ha is extremely lacking. yaml is rubbish language
ha is like the ios of automation and openhab is like the android. depends on what you prefer
 
Last edited:

pleasefatladysing

Junior Member
Joined
Apr 14, 2017
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Starting with Apple HomeKit

Hello. I am looking to start my home automation with Apple HomeKit. What are the recommended products to get started?

I want to be able to turn on and off lights and fans. Bonus if I can control air con too.
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top