Penrose Sims Villa

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
Why ppl so hesitant abt staying in penrose area haha.. making me think twice now. My thinking is if geylang core i def wont stay. But that outskirt of geylang is ok? Far away enough from the geylang activity but yet near enough to enjoy the convenience

Hehe don’t take our words wholesale, perhaps it’s good for u to drive there and experience the vibes yourself. If possible, try walk from there to mrt and feel if it’s acceptable for u.
Feeling and vibes is a very subjective thing.

That said, I’m gonna give it another chance and will drive there again later since the price looks decent :D
 

drkcynic

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2007
Messages
57,430
Reaction score
26,943
Afterall, PPR will still lead the pack in terms of rental and resales in D14. If PPR sux in both, the rest are not spared either. Then the next dimension to look at is entry price Liao. Who enter lower plays an impt part in rental yield and cap gain.

I felt PR can still consider given its Low psf and entry price.
But to stay there I’m not too sure :D

I think PPR and PR location 差很远. Taking aside the differential in rental returns, I believe the rental demand at PPR will also be much higher than PR. After PR is up, there will be 1600 units in that corner!

High supply, low demand, low returns, difficult for me to hoot.
 

sinequa88

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2020
Messages
531
Reaction score
15
At this Penrose pricing of 14xx-15xxpsf, does it mean those who buy Parc Esta at 16xxpsf is stuck? PE has more than >1000 units.. so assume 50% did not buy during launch at 15xxpsf, then at least 500 owners now stuck with PE with low chance of appreciation?

I mean if a resale buyer were to buy into D14 in the future, Penrose will likely be the 2nd project they look into ( after PPR) cause not only cheapest (cause 1st owner can let go at 16xxpsf and still earn decent profits), nearer to city centre, and less cramped as well. Whatever PE has, PR has even better!

PE will be the 3rd choice to look at after PPR and PR

Make sense?

I think penrose prices have shaken things up a bit unexpectedly. That said, it’s not an apples to apples comparison. There is no question that the PIE units will have a pricing advantage compared to the road facing PE units. (14xx Vs 15xx-16xx) The pricing of the inner facing units remains to be seen.
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
I think PPR and PR location 差很远. Taking aside the differential in rental returns, I believe the rental demand at PPR will also be much higher than PR. After PR is up, there will be 1600 units in that corner!

High supply, low demand, low returns, difficult for me to hoot.

1600 unit side by side sure can’t run away from competition. Plus PE is in a better location than SUO/PR.

Bro just a word of caution, Sims residence though 112 units in total, but rental transaction like not a lot, only 7 transaction this year. So consider carefully first :)
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
I think penrose prices have shaken things up a bit unexpectedly. That said, it’s not an apples to apples comparison. There is no question that the PIE units will have a pricing advantage compared to the road facing PE units. (14xx Vs 15xx-16xx) The pricing of the inner facing units remains to be seen.

Yap, the pricing for inner facing for PR may still very much in 16xxpsf range probably.
For same psf, will go for PE rather.

PIE facing is the one that has enticing pricing, but that also means living quality need to be compromised.
 

drkcynic

Great Supremacy Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2007
Messages
57,430
Reaction score
26,943
1600 unit side by side sure can’t run away from competition. Plus PE is in a better location than SUO/PR.

Bro just a word of caution, Sims residence though 112 units in total, but rental transaction like not a lot, only 7 transaction this year. So consider carefully first :)

Thanks boss! Yes I am wary of small developments which has too many ownstay profiles.
 

sinequa88

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2020
Messages
531
Reaction score
15
the 1 bedder inward facing is 1,665 psf while 4 bedder inward facing is 1,520 psf. From this we know the psf for the 2/3 bedder inward facing will be in between.

The inner facing stacks are also broadly spaced out into 2 tiers. Lower tier stacks being closer to the opposite block and no direct pool view with some line of sight with the driveway. The other higher tier has better distance between blocks and a proper pool view.

Obvious there will be further differentiated pricing.
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
the 1 bedder inward facing is 1,665 psf while 4 bedder inward facing is 1,520 psf. From this we know the psf for the 2/3 bedder inward facing will be in between.

The inner facing stacks are also broadly spaced out into 2 tiers. Lower tier stacks being closer to the opposite block and no direct pool view with some line of sight with the driveway. The other higher tier has better distance between blocks and a proper pool view.

Obvious there will be further differentiated pricing.

Yes, inner facing pricing so so nia for PR.
That’s y I’m not really excited about the 1 bedder pool facing units.
This project I will only look for lowest quantum/psf. :D
 

homechaser

Member
Joined
Aug 31, 2020
Messages
211
Reaction score
17
NSZ, any thoughts on 2+1S units how pricing will be like and yr thoughts on those for ownstay?
Yes, inner facing pricing so so nia for PR.
That’s y I’m not really excited about the 1 bedder pool facing units.
This project I will only look for lowest quantum/psf. :D
 

propertyinvestor40

Master Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2020
Messages
3,973
Reaction score
1,168
Ppl who buy parc esta at 1800-1900 now surely regret.
Penrose 1400 only lelong lelong.
Plus aljunied is nearer to city than eunos. Gg
 

NiShiZhu

Banned
Joined
Jan 27, 2005
Messages
9,297
Reaction score
3,015
Just did a thorough site visit for 3rd time and try walking from mrt to PR, took me around 8mins-10mins under hot sun. Unsheltered. Not a pleasant walk though.
The surrounding has one wet market and hawker nearby but the entire Surrounding feels depressing. Probably surrounded by old hdb and industrial estate and nothing much. There’s one nexus intl school but it’s quite dead too. Now they are tearing down the old hdb next to it and probably building bto.
Ok will give it a miss. Really nothing spectacular or special.

DPdRoAy.jpg
 

Ohw123

Senior Member
Joined
May 9, 2020
Messages
1,391
Reaction score
1
Ppl who buy parc esta at 1800-1900 now surely regret.
Penrose 1400 only lelong lelong.
Plus aljunied is nearer to city than eunos. Gg

What 1400 only? Expressway facing starts from 1417psf, if ppl want inward pool facing or road facing, should be at least 1500psf ba. Parc Esta quality and location way better than Penrose.
 

sinequa88

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 28, 2020
Messages
531
Reaction score
15
Just did a thorough site visit for 3rd time and try walking from mrt to PR, took me around 8mins-10mins under hot sun. Unsheltered. Not a pleasant walk though.
The surrounding has one wet market and hawker nearby but the entire Surrounding feels depressing. Probably surrounded by old hdb and industrial estate and nothing much. There’s one nexus intl school but it’s quite dead too. Now they are tearing down the old hdb next to it and probably building bto.
Ok will give it a miss. Really nothing spectacular or special.

DPdRoAy.jpg

Later CDL pick this message up and price down further to 13xx

Don’t like that ar... haha:s13:
 

Falafell

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2020
Messages
1,141
Reaction score
388
Just did a thorough site visit for 3rd time and try walking from mrt to PR, took me around 8mins-10mins under hot sun. Unsheltered. Not a pleasant walk though.
The surrounding has one wet market and hawker nearby but the entire Surrounding feels depressing. Probably surrounded by old hdb and industrial estate and nothing much. There’s one nexus intl school but it’s quite dead too. Now they are tearing down the old hdb next to it and probably building bto.
Ok will give it a miss. Really nothing spectacular or special.

DPdRoAy.jpg

Agree with you, I was there to visit before & during SUO launched though I did not visit the area where the hawker and wet market is.

In the perspective of homestay, coming back from Aljunied MRT you are quickly greeted by the food stretch of the outskirts of Geylang (although i rmb the curry fishhead quite nice). You have to cross the overhead bridge past a busy Aljunied road and there begins the 8-10 mins walk back home. A narrow unsheltered walkway flanged with office/industrial buildings (usually very dead and wall like, how nice if you can walk inside with cafes around) on the left and Geylang Methodist on the right. Upon reaching the junction, you are greeted by SUO (which is actually quite pretty) and old HDBs across the right of the junction. Roads are always busy all the time.

If I'm buying the PIE facing units, I think it can feel even more depressing.
 

urbanmale2004

Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2020
Messages
154
Reaction score
0
Later CDL pick this message up and price down further to 13xx

Don’t like that ar... haha:s13:
its feels like indeed in a depressing locale.

Initially was interested in the 1br, but from the indicative pricing of 1666psf to start from the lowest floor likely for stack 4, the 10th floor will easily hit $1877 psf. And another premium added on for the better 1br stack 13. Did my analysis and dont seems cheap actually. Its just priced normal.

The fact that my interest have drops drastically with the pricing and the not ideal location. am gonna skipped penrose and take back my cheque. Give other people a chance. 😂😂😂
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top