[ST] How WP won over Sengkang

[aspenco]

tbh, the win came as a sweet surprise. the pap candidates had pretty strong profile. good for sengkang, at least these folks knew the importance of having proper checks and balances in parliament.

 

[Sminsky]

The incumbent focused on East Coast GRC. I think it was the live debate that sealed Sengkang’s fate. They didn’t know a newcomer, Dr Jamus was so well eloquent, his summary sealed it. Simple and short, no blank cheque.

I think so too. If not for the debate, hardly ppl will know Jamus. The organiser seemed to do WP a favor.

 

[topiari]

My mother 70+ years old voted for WP in Sengkang... I asked her why??? I tot old ppl sure vote PAP..

She told me she very angry with the increase in costs of living.. everything becoming so expensive.. She told me go ntuc buy can food used to be $1.80, now $3 just within 1+ year...

I think costs of living is one major problem... imagine the increase in GST kicks in.. no joke.

But reality is today she goes to emptyUC to buy can food is still $3
With GST increase looming, maybe more in the future

 

[_eMuu_]

Its not about strategy nor about opposition.

Its about pap screwed up. Mis-handle the virus. Cause ppl to lose job while they scold ppl xia suay.

Sent from Space using GAGT

 

[HWANGCHEOLBUM]

I think so too. If not for the debate, hardly ppl will know Jamus. The organiser seemed to do WP a favor.

I’m thinking if East Coast GRC could have been won for WP if they send someone there to debate in the mandarin version.

 

[062692J]

Dont think they dare to go ahead and stir the khan case, votes sure go even further down...

 

[iceblendedchoc]

Observers cite candidates who resonated with younger voters; a desire for checks and balances; and the national swing towards opposition

One of the early signs that not all may be well came midway in the campaign.

Clad in white, Mr Ng Chee Meng and Mr Amrin Amin went around Sengkang Central, waving and introducing themselves. Usually, residents obliged with a smile or a nod, even if hesitantly.

But there were some who gave the two People's Action Party (PAP) candidates the cold shoulder, to the point of being outright unfriendly.

"I could tell from their interactions, from their body language, that they were a bit hostile," said a party volunteer on residents that the candidates had approached.

Alarm bells rang. The PAP team - which also included Senior Minister of State for Transport and Health Lam Pin Min, 50, and lawyer Raymond Lye, 54 - redoubled its efforts.

On social media, there were photographs of Mr Ng, 51, a former defence chief, sprinting up and down Housing Board block corridors, trying to reach as many residents as possible in the remaining days of the campaign.

In the end, it was too little, too late. On Polling Day, Sengkang GRC emerged as the biggest upset of the 2020 General Election.

The Workers' Party (WP) won with 52.13 per cent of the votes, against a 47.87 per cent share for the PAP. This meant that three political office-holders, including Mr Ng - who is labour chief and a core member of the 4G leadership - have been turfed out.

"Everybody was surprised, shocked," a party volunteer said.

-
-
-

A MISCALCULATION

For the ruling party, it was not meant to be like this. Singapore's newest group representation constituency, created just ahead of this general election, was widely thought to be safe, albeit closely contested, for the men in white.

Ahead of the hustings, attention focused more on the eastern flank of Singapore such as East Coast GRC, where the WP had made some inroads during previous elections.

Sengkang GRC is made up of Sengkang Central - previously helmed by Mr Teo Ser Luck and which was part of Pasir Ris-Punggol GRC which clinched a high 72.89 per cent of the votes in 2015; part of Sengkang West, where Dr Lam won a respectable 62.13 per cent; and Punggol East which stalwart Charles Chong wrested from WP incumbent Lee Li Lian with 51.77 per cent.

The 120,100 voters were mainly young couples living in HDB estates - a constituent group traditionally thought to not want to rock the boat too much as they build up their first homes.

Of the three men, only Dr Lam - who has been at Sengkang West since he entered politics in 2006 - remained in the political fray this time round, with the retirement of Mr Chong and Mr Teo from politics.

Sengkang Central was partitioned into two, to be represented by Mr Ng and Mr Amrin, previously from Pasir Ris-Punggol GRC and Sembawang GRC respectively. Punggol East was to be represented by Mr Lye, a long-time grassroots leader.

In the end, Sengkang Central and Punggol East did not do well at the ballot box, with Sengkang West faring slightly better, party insiders said.

-
-
-

For now, a preliminary assessment among some is that it could have been a miscalculation to parachute in three faces unfamiliar to the constituency. ST understands that Mr Amrin, who is Senior Parliamentary Secretary for Home Affairs and Health, started walking the ground as a potential candidate only some time in the last six months or so, while Mr Ng began towards the end of last year.

A PAP insider said: "It was a problem with strategy. Ng Chee Meng and Amrin entered late in the game - but the calculation was that they are office-holders and there wouldn't be a problem. Also, the vote share previously was quite high so they thought it was safe."

Some residents said they voted for WP as they liked the party's policy proposals, and because they felt little affinity with their former elected representatives.

Ms Tan Siew Eng, 50, who has lived in Sengkang for over 20 years under various PAP MPs due to the changing electoral boundaries, said she hardly sees them in the neighbourhood. Added Ms Tan, who works in a non-profit organisation: "It doesn't really matter to me whether they are there or not."

-
-
-

YOUNG PARENTS, YOUNG STARS

The game also changed significantly when the campaign began.

A televised debate on the day after Nomination Day elevated Prof Lim to a political star, after he easily held his own against veteran PAP debater-minister Vivian Balakrishnan. Across Singapore, plaudits rolled in. As one PAP observer noted: "There was the Jamus Lim effect - and we had nothing to neutralise that."

Another candidate on the WP's Sengkang slate who stirred excitement was Ms Raeesah, who at 26, was the party's youngest candidate. She is a social activist who started the Reyna Movement to empower women.

Within the mix is also Ms He, who had her own cachet. When she entered politics in 2015, the Cambridge natural sciences graduate, who later went on to read law in London, was quickly heralded as the new Nicole Seah.

Ms Seah was a star candidate from the National Solidarity Party in 2011, although she quit in 2014 and joined the WP the year after.

Less well known is the WP team's last member, Mr Chua, but he has spoken persuasively about building a more resilient society with a greater diversity of voices in Parliament.

At the same time, the slate of four also managed to position themselves as young parents who could identify with the aspirations and challenges of the residents they wanted to serve.

This was important: More than 60 per cent of Sengkang GRC residents are aged below 45, and over one in 20 is younger than five - both above the national rates.

As political observer Kevin Tan, who is also an author and historian, said during a webinar yesterday: "The WP had a brilliant campaign, (fielding) young candidates, trying to dovetail their own identities with that of the young families, young parents who lived in Sengkang."

-
-
-

NO DIRTY POLITICS

Another issue that gained traction among the young voters was what many perceived to be a smear campaign against the opposition.

On the last weekend before Polling Day, police reports were lodged against Ms Raeesah for social media comments that allegedly promoted racial or religious enmity - and likely ricocheted in hurting the PAP instead, said observers.

Assistant Professor Walid Jumblatt Abdullah from Nanyang Technological University's School of Social Sciences said: "Younger voters and minorities were quite upset at how they perceived her to be treated, and I think, this should demonstrate to the 4G that perhaps a new approach towards politics is needed."

-
-
-

NATIONAL SWING

Ultimately, what happened in Sengkang cannot be divorced from the nationwide swing towards the opposition.

Overall, the PAP attained 61.2 per cent of the popular vote - down from the 69.9 per cent in 2015.

In particular, the WP scored 50.49 per cent in the constituencies it contested in.

This means that more people voted for the WP than those who did not, suggesting that its message of not giving the PAP a blank cheque resonated strongly.

NUS' Prof Tan said: "There is a swing across the board, almost entirely. This suggests that the arguments pointing out the need for checks and balances, and the call to deny PAP a super majority in Parliament, did have some resonance."

Many residents, such as Ms Tan and Mr V. T. Nathan, a retired sales manager, feel that it was important for there to be a diversity of voices in Parliament.

"For every issue, there will be many different perspectives," said Ms Tan. "If we can ensure that there is a diversity of voices in Parliament, it would ensure that issues are debated robustly before being passed."

-
-
-

RECIPE FOR SUCCESS?

THE JAMUS EFFECT

A televised debate on the day after Nomination Day elevated Associate Professor Jamus Lim to a political star, after he easily held his own against veteran PAP debater-minister Vivian Balakrishnan. Across Singapore, plaudits rolled in. As one PAP observer noted: "There was the Jamus Lim effect - and we had nothing to neutralise that."

THE RAEESAH FACTOR

On the last weekend before Polling Day, police reports were lodged against Ms Raeesah Khan for social media comments that allegedly promoted racial or religious enmity.

Assistant Professor Walid Jumblatt Abdullah from Nanyang Technological University's School of Social Sciences said: "Younger voters and minorities were quite upset at how they perceived her to be treated."

https://www.straitstimes.com/politics/how-wp-won-over-sengkang

On making police reports , that definitely backfire! Anyone with a decent mind and average IQ will see that it was politically motivated because of the timing. Of course , the stupid one will remain stupid as stupidity has no cure so far in this modern age am thus far.

 

[Pocoyoz]

It is an upset precisely because it is a newly created GRC.

You all don't know how grc are created meh? It is always in favour of the men in white. They canvas swee swee already and have info before hand.

Last time ah gong use newly created grc to split up oppositions.

Do they know beforehand the existence and boundaries of the new grc?
Self pwned article

Sent from Amazon using GAGT

 

[TopGun]

I think so too. If not for the debate, hardly ppl will know Jamus. The organiser seemed to do WP a favor.

I guess it was meant for the opposite to happen instead. That Vivian would 'trash' the opposition and provide fodder for the press for the days to come...

 

[woolff]

Lessons to all pap mp. Do your job and don’t **** around. The People will definitely vote you out not like the PG...

 

[brianlee_73]

The PMD saga is damned if you do, damned if you don’t situation.
If he didn’t ban the PMD, I think he may lose even more votes.
It is simply due to poor planning and this saga don’t not have started in the first place.

 

[aarontansp]

young couples know how hard it is to find a job. and we see **** and jhk merrying around. what they are doing is meant for the many unemployed sinkies

 

[Chromesthlesia]

Another rubbish article by 158th experts misleading readers. All the real reasons like ****, poor economic performance, poor covid response + the Dorm, play race card president, using parliament as court resulting in lost of trust and most importantly 158 losing influence to new media were not mentioned. 158th showed they are reaching irrelevance this GE, don talk abt next. If PAP reads and believes 158th experts, they be prepared to lose more votes.
SK is big (bigger than Aljunied), PAP lost is even bigger 1xminister, 1xMOS, 1xPS; combined is 1 falcon punch. Now the scourge from AHTC has extended north to SK, just next to Punggol, helm by a retiring TCH, things are not looking good.

Sengkang is strawberry generation... you notice that the people fielded are around 20s to 40s people that resonate with young couple.

Go Aljunied u need to field people around the same grp.

Go Hougang is MG/PG group, field and strategise on different topics.

Maybe the points u are talking abt is the MG group for Aljunied/Hougang

 

[cnotsniw]

So easy to play the blame game and make sweeping statements it's the younger generation fault. Why no critical analysis of own policies impact on everyone, not just younger generation?

 

[Matjes]

The PMD saga is damned if you do, damned if you don’t situation.
If he didn’t ban the PMD, I think he may lose even more votes.
It is simply due to poor planning and this saga don’t not have started in the first place.

How about pushing for infrastructure and laws for PMD rather than quick fix band aid by banning them?

Lazy complacent Lam. Time to replace him.

 

[sbv7230]

Is ST relevant anymore?
158 and counting..
Pui Pui Pui....

 

[alvincy]

Means that Abdul Malik single handedly brought down PAP Sengkang team.

 

[fandango]

From Malay friends. The whole community was very upset with PAP for kicking up a fuss over the Raeesah issue.

The Berita Harian report on on Raeesah was factual, non opinion, and only found in one day. Where as Strait Times spent a few days and editorial on Raeesah. It is a very sensitive issue.

Possibly almost all malay votes went to WP.

 

[Mr Brown]

They overestimated the ‘abilities’ of NCM & Amin lah. Then Lam practically dug his own grave with the PMD controversy.

If want to parachute NCM, they shld have read edmw first


Put Charles Chong or Teo Ser Luck also better than NCM


NCM was practically villified n slaughtered by netizens, still kay khiang promise more sheltered walkways and lift upgrades if elected

 

[Chromesthlesia]

Play victim card says people outright hostile
This is the real reason that they are so high up they think they are the master of the land
Surprise here surprise there
Put tank in a mall

Young voter here; I don't like smear campaigns and high-handedness. The analysis is true for me and I grew up in a generation where I go to my Malay and Indian friends houses for house visiting.

The underlying racism is real.