Same here, the sales in SF, on Sutter Street did impressed me enough to drop money on my first pair of AEs. That and with Comgateway was how I ended up with 7 pairs of AEs. Probably good to last me for the next 5-10 years

It's probably not as value for money now that USD has risen almost 10% against SGD since then.
That said, Carmina really is on another playing field in regards to leather quality and aesthetic. If given a chance to reallocate my shoe funds again, I'll buy a couple of AE classics daily beaters (Strands, McAllister/Cambridge) + Alden Cordovan Indys and spend the rest of the funds on Carminas or Vass. I'll also reduce the amount of money spent on shoe care
Less is more I guess in this case of limited funds and poison galore, better to save up and get the pair you want instead having 2-3 pairs of shoes you don't mind having around