[Official] Home Automation Thread

pustefix

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
537
Reaction score
10
As someone had said, using Echo/GH to control your devices is not home automation, it is just a voice remote. The ultimate goal should be turning on/off devices automatically, e.g. light turns on when you enter a room, everything turns off when you leave your house, etc. For cases where it is difficult or impossible to automate, then you can fall back to using voice or other means to control the devices.

From my experience, if I need to control the device daily and I can't automate it, I will still prefer to use a wireless switch then to use voice. Using voice has lag and once you are used to instantaneous feedback, any lag is bad. Since we are used to pressing button to turn on/off devices, it seems more intuitive then to use voice. However, there are certain scenarios where using voice is preferred, e.g. when your hands are not free like carrying a baby, when you don't use it daily like setting movie mode, etc.
 

wahjohreno

Master Member
Joined
May 15, 2017
Messages
3,382
Reaction score
216
As someone had said, using Echo/GH to control your devices is not home automation, it is just a voice remote. The ultimate goal should be turning on/off devices automatically, e.g. light turns on when you enter a room, everything turns off when you leave your house, etc. For cases where it is difficult or impossible to automate, then you can fall back to using voice or other means to control the devices.

From my experience, if I need to control the device daily and I can't automate it, I will still prefer to use a wireless switch then to use voice. Using voice has lag and once you are used to instantaneous feedback, any lag is bad. Since we are used to pressing button to turn on/off devices, it seems more intuitive then to use voice. However, there are certain scenarios where using voice is preferred, e.g. when your hands are not free like carrying a baby, when you don't use it daily like setting movie mode, etc.
Yes, there are many scenes that can be programmed to happen automatically based on phone location, sensor readings, schedule...etc.

But from my own experience, it’s only half the story at most.

Many times, issuing commands while hands are full or while walking seems to be more common.

With a HA bridge, the lag is barely discernible. Less than a second. It’s very acceptable.
 

Revealed

Banned
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
68
Reaction score
0
While I agree home automation is more than just using voice for direct control, I think It's very hard to go fully automatic. Today you walk into a room, you may want the air con to be switched on because you just finish playing sport playing sports. The next day, maybe you are walking around naked and you prefer just lights switched on.

Use of voice do comes with lag. I think if you don't have sensors installed, you should change your lifestyle too. For instance, I used to walk to kitchen and ask the kitchen lights to be switched on. I have to wait a few moments in the dark kitchen. Now, I call for the lights to be turned on as I am on my way there and the place will be lighted up before or as I reach.


As someone had said, using Echo/GH to control your devices is not home automation, it is just a voice remote. The ultimate goal should be turning on/off devices automatically, e.g. light turns on when you enter a room, everything turns off when you leave your house, etc. For cases where it is difficult or impossible to automate, then you can fall back to using voice or other means to control the devices.

From my experience, if I need to control the device daily and I can't automate it, I will still prefer to use a wireless switch then to use voice. Using voice has lag and once you are used to instantaneous feedback, any lag is bad. Since we are used to pressing button to turn on/off devices, it seems more intuitive then to use voice. However, there are certain scenarios where using voice is preferred, e.g. when your hands are not free like carrying a baby, when you don't use it daily like setting movie mode, etc.
 

wahjohreno

Master Member
Joined
May 15, 2017
Messages
3,382
Reaction score
216
While I agree home automation is more than just using voice for direct control, I think It's very hard to go fully automatic. Today you walk into a room, you may want the air con to be switched on because you just finish playing sport playing sports. The next day, maybe you are walking around naked and you prefer just lights switched on.

Use of voice do comes with lag. I think if you don't have sensors installed, you should change your lifestyle too. For instance, I used to walk to kitchen and ask the kitchen lights to be switched on. I have to wait a few moments in the dark kitchen. Now, I call for the lights to be turned on as I am on my way there and the place will be lighted up before or as I reach.

HA bridge bro. Before I installed it, the lag was 3-4 secs. After, it's 1 sec at most. Well worth it.
 

pustefix

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
537
Reaction score
10
Yes, I agree that there are a lot of cases where automation is hard/impossible. You can do an experiment by putting a wireless switch in one room, as you enter, press it to turn on the light. You will find that most people will just use that switch to turn on the lights instead of using voice command, it is more intuitive and faster. As the switch is wireless, you can place it anywhere convenient and program it to do different things. Of course there is cost to the switch but my argument is that it is more intuitive than to use voice.
 

gheesung

Junior Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2000
Messages
49
Reaction score
0
As someone had said, using Echo/GH to control your devices is not home automation, it is just a voice remote. The ultimate goal should be turning on/off devices automatically, e.g. light turns on when you enter a room, everything turns off when you leave your house, etc. For cases where it is difficult or impossible to automate, then you can fall back to using voice or other means to control the devices.

From my experience, if I need to control the device daily and I can't automate it, I will still prefer to use a wireless switch then to use voice. Using voice has lag and once you are used to instantaneous feedback, any lag is bad. Since we are used to pressing button to turn on/off devices, it seems more intuitive then to use voice. However, there are certain scenarios where using voice is preferred, e.g. when your hands are not free like carrying a baby, when you don't use it daily like setting movie mode, etc.

A nice home automation experience is good to have with sensor inputs or external data input. The example 2 use cases I have done are:

1. Turn on the door entrance light when the door is open when the Astro timing is evening. At different time of the year, the Sunset hour is different and Sunset and Sunrise timing can easily obtain using Astro time.

2. Turn on the kitchen light based on motion and lux reading of the kitchen. During the day time, the kitchen is bright enough that light needs not to turn on when motion is detected.

I have implemented these using Openhab, Xiaomi door switch and motion sensor.
 

Revealed

Banned
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
68
Reaction score
0
Personally, I think intuitive also comes from past experience. Maybe after 21 days of using voice, it will be more intuitive to use voice. :)

Yes, I agree that there are a lot of cases where automation is hard/impossible. You can do an experiment by putting a wireless switch in one room, as you enter, press it to turn on the light. You will find that most people will just use that switch to turn on the lights instead of using voice command, it is more intuitive and faster. As the switch is wireless, you can place it anywhere convenient and program it to do different things. Of course there is cost to the switch but my argument is that it is more intuitive than to use voice.
 

wahjohreno

Master Member
Joined
May 15, 2017
Messages
3,382
Reaction score
216
My lag is mainly due to Google home processing the command

Yes. The 3-4 sec lag I had was due to Alexa’s processing time. I couldn’t live with it, and my home automation guy suggested the HA bridge.

Installing a HA bridge cut the 3-4 sec lag down to less than 1 sec. At the time I paid like $80 for it (basically a raspberry pi loaded with HA bridge). Some of the best money I’ve spent in my life.
 
Last edited:

viix

Master Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2
While I agree home automation is more than just using voice for direct control, I think It's very hard to go fully automatic. Today you walk into a room, you may want the air con to be switched on because you just finish playing sport playing sports. The next day, maybe you are walking around naked and you prefer just lights switched on.

Use of voice do comes with lag. I think if you don't have sensors installed, you should change your lifestyle too. For instance, I used to walk to kitchen and ask the kitchen lights to be switched on. I have to wait a few moments in the dark kitchen. Now, I call for the lights to be turned on as I am on my way there and the place will be lighted up before or as I reach.

All these can be done with presence scoring. ie, I set a countdown on my water sensor after my shower, I set "scores" on a variable so if homey detects I was in the toilet more than 10min, water heater was on, and I just came back, it "guesses" I was in the shower and sets a specific temperature for my aircon.

I also score my sensor to "predict" my walking direction. If walking from room motion sensor, past door sensor, past corridor sensor, head past dining hall sensor, all these will add a score to my variable and if score is a certain amount, turn on kitchen light. If I turn left to the balcony, score will be a different value and instead balcony lights turn on.

I program my automation base on scores. each sensor has a defined value. Log the different ingress and egress routes and slowly u will see a pattern and u can start understanding your behaviour and program your automation to work for u.

with this data, u actually can realise human always do the same thing. the deviation isn't much and you can compensate these deviation with IFTTT or time to change the automation.

I also set it up such that my ical is sync to my homey. If the event has a keyword "cycling", it will also score that Im coming home sweaty and turn on aircon when my geolocation is past my preset radius.

It's not difficult to program such logic as long as u break down the variables. I did it on homey with over 500 automation rules over the course of the past year.

Would be better if there was machine learning to "Learn my habit" but my presence scoring works.. hit rate is 8 out of 10 times accurate so I'm pretty happy. Heck I don't even command my voice assistant as much except for asking questions.
 
Last edited:

Revealed

Banned
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
68
Reaction score
0
Nice. Wow. Must have taken much time to set those rules. If only it can be integrated with cctv and it can in real life predict where we are going.



All these can be done with presence scoring. ie, I set a countdown on my water sensor after my shower, I set "scores" on a variable so if homey detects I was in the toilet more than 10min, water heater was on, and I just came back, it "guesses" I was in the shower and sets a specific temperature for my aircon.

I also score my sensor to "predict" my walking direction. If walking from room motion sensor, past door sensor, past corridor sensor, head past dining hall sensor, all these will add a score to my variable and if score is a certain amount, turn on kitchen light. If I turn left to the balcony, score will be a different value and instead balcony lights turn on.

I program my automation base on scores. each sensor has a defined value. Log the different ingress and egress routes and slowly u will see a pattern and u can start understanding your behaviour and program your automation to work for u.

with this data, u actually can realise human always do the same thing. the deviation isn't much and you can compensate these deviation with IFTTT or time to change the automation.

I also set it up such that my ical is sync to my homey. If the event has a keyword "cycling", it will also score that Im coming home sweaty and turn on aircon when my geolocation is past my preset radius.

It's not difficult to program such logic as long as u break down the variables. I did it on homey with over 500 automation rules over the course of the past year.

Would be better if there was machine learning to "Learn my habit" but my presence scoring works.. hit rate is 8 out of 10 times accurate so I'm pretty happy. Heck I don't even command my voice assistant as much except for asking questions.
 

Revealed

Banned
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
68
Reaction score
0
I see. So each Alexa would require a bridge?


Yes. The 3-4 sec lag I had was due to Alexa’s processing time. I couldn’t live with it, and my home automation guy suggested the HA bridge.

Installing a HA bridge cut the 3-4 sec lag down to less than 1 sec. At the time I paid like $80 for it (basically a raspberry pi loaded with HA bridge). Some of the best money I’ve spent in my life.
 

viix

Master Member
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,236
Reaction score
2
Nice. Wow. Must have taken much time to set those rules. If only it can be integrated with cctv and it can in real life predict where we are going.

It’s the insights logging that took time to understand my habits and trial and error on sensor placements to limit overlaps of the floor plan/zone.. Then put it into a matrix table and tabulate a “score” with excel Lor. Implementing it is quite fast.. trick is not to over complicate it..
 
Important Forum Advisory Note
This forum is moderated by volunteer moderators who will react only to members' feedback on posts. Moderators are not employees or representatives of HWZ Forums. Forum members and moderators are responsible for their own posts. Please refer to our Community Guidelines and Standards and Terms and Conditions for more information.
Top