Smart

Usual hype la, when u sell at 1000psf 5 yrs later den tink its a profit when it barely covers much
I agree, i think the gain from an EC is over hyped. I am getting married next year so have been examining the market quite closely. One thing that everyone forgets is time value of money with the differerence you pay between a good location hdb and an EC.
Lets say EC 3rm sells around 770k-780k for mid floor. Assuming buyer is first timer with 30k grant, 110k cpf, 50k cash, then loan is ard 600k.
For a 4 bedroom resale flat you're looking at between 500k to max 650k depending on location. So assuming same buyer your loan is about say on the high side 460k. (Assuming if you buy a resale hdb you have to keep some $ for reno)
Now the difference in monthly mortgage, plus the slightly higher condo maintainence fee is around 870 a month. Assuming you take this $ and invest for 10 years at an interest rate of 5%, which is not very difficult, then after 10 years, you would get after 10 years about $130,000, reflecting a gain of 26% from the investment. This is independent of any gain you may get from selling the flat in itself, so in essence you are more 'diversified'. Lets assume a modest price appreciation of 10% of flat price. At the end of the 10 years you would have gained 65000+ 130000 = 190000.
Back to the EC: assuming starting price is about 850 psf and the price appreciates to 1200 psf, then the gain is 41%. However, this gain is ONLY realised upon selling the EC, and is dependent on the housing market. In this scenario you are treating the entire worth of your house as an inbestment so you are 780k vested in the housing market. To me this is a rather risky strategy. Remember, you still need a home, what if you cant sell at your desired price?
Nevertheless, if we assume that you can indeed sell the house for your 1200 psf and you bought at 850 psf, then your gain after 10 years is 330,000 (assume 950 sqft ec.)
Gains compared:
Resale hdb + investment: 190k, of which 130k is highly liquid and not dependent on housing market
EC: 330k, all of which os dependent on housing market and is illiqiuid
So of course you gain more from the ec but this is a highly risky strategy and i feel EC is an overhyped investment vehicle.