While either way is fine, PetiaC is right and it has been my preferred method for years. I find that wearing a few times would encourage the "natural flex" on the leather uppers and reduce the tendency that the topy will come apart. Also wearing it a few times will increase the surface area on the soles for the rubber to adhere to but that may not be necessary since every cobbler worth his paycheck would file them roughly before applying adhesive.
I have had shoes topied when new and while the difference is minimal on single sole shoes, I find that they can be quite unyieldy on already stiff double sole shoes and have since preferred to break into my shoes a couple of wears before I send them for topy. Incidentally, it is actually a good way to check if the shoes fit well before you commit abit more money to topy them.
I have had shoes topied when new and while the difference is minimal on single sole shoes, I find that they can be quite unyieldy on already stiff double sole shoes and have since preferred to break into my shoes a couple of wears before I send them for topy. Incidentally, it is actually a good way to check if the shoes fit well before you commit abit more money to topy them.
